Neil Reynolds

I like him, he provides a good balance to the show with his journalism/media background in opposition to the ex-pro they normally have on the coverage.

Nick was good too, but I got irritated sometimes by his obvious preference for certain teams and his pandering to the ex-pro...Mike Carlson is the best however!

Reynolds is a god as is Cecil Martin, make a very good punditry team.

nick gone to front the boxing...a shame.
at least kegs still there,

i prefer reynolds personally,

i've always found halling a bit patronising.

Reynolds has a very annoying voice. I appreciate that he's worked hard to get where he is and I respect that. He has plenty of knowledge of the game, NFL and college, but I find him quite TV unfriendly over a 6 hour show.

He is the least charismatic man on television.
I never actually see him doing any analyzing of his own, maybe a quick five minute snip before the game. But usually that just consists of why Tom Brady will have a great game or how the St. Louis Rams can't stop the run. Thanks Neil, very insightful.

Now I respect the guy, he's obviously worked hard and rather well to get where he is and I don't doubt that he has a good knowledge of the game but please do something other than read out e-mails for the guests to answer.
Sky Sports coverage of the NFL is very poor in my opinion.