Comment deleted by Site Moderator

nice one Raptor

Theyre both not the greatest.. however list 1 wins

Star Wars - not a fan
Gladiator - not a fan
Point Break - not a fan
Any Given Sunday - never seen it
Mississippi Burning - never seen it
Footloose (remake) - never seen it
Déjà vu - Liked it
Pulp Fiction - liked it
Stand By Me - never seen it
Boys n the Hood - great film
28 Days Later - good film
Capricorn One - never seen it
Spy Game - never seen it
Runaway Train (original) - never seen it
Australia - never seen it
American Werewolf in London - never seen it
The Getaway (original) - never seen it
State of Grace - never seen it
Manhunter - never seen it
True Romance - never seen it
Swimming Pool - never seen it
The Commitments - never seen it

LIST 2

taxi driver - never seen it
apocalypse now - never seen it
come and see - never seen it
pretty village pretty flame - never seen it
stalker - never seen it
oldboy - never seen it
deer hunter - never seen it
sonatine - never seen it
thin red line - never seen it
martyrs - never seen it
raging bull - never seen it
the good the bad and the ugly - never seen it
2001 - never seen it
la haine - never seen it
casino - never seen it
sympathy for mr vengance - never seen it
city of life and death - never seen it
hana bi - never seen it
paths of glory - never seen it
enter the void - never seen it
the simpsons - liked it
bill and ted's excellent adventure - great film

Thought id explain why.. ?

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

havent seen most of those.

where is tera patrick aka filthywhore?

list 1 easily

1.

Oldboy is a train wreck of a film.

Star Wars
Gladiator
Pulp Fiction
Stand By Me
Boys n the Hood
28 Days Later

vs.

Casino
the good the bad and the ugly

blimmy some bad films there ,.................

LIST 2

taxi driver
apocalypse now
come and see
pretty village pretty flame
stalker
oldboy
deer hunter
sonatine
thin red line
martyrs
raging bull
the good the bad and the ugly
2001
la haine
casino
sympathy for mr vengance
city of life and death
hana bi
paths of glory
enter the void
the simpsons
bill and ted's excellent adventure

this list is obviously from someone trying to be a 'film buff' some s actually think its a badge of honour to be sitting in a flat somewhere watching shiet films on their own
List 1 wins all day

Where is Weekend at Bernies 2?

Both lists FAIL!

list 1....

where is inglorious basterrrrdddrds? i watched that for the first time last weekend

there's 2 brad pitt films up there chronic (true romance and spy games). i actually think he is an excellent actor.

i saw the new one killing them softly a couple of days ago, which is pretty decent too

Star Wars.....but no Ferris Bueller?

Star Wars - a classic
Gladiator - a classic
Point Break - quality
Any Given Sunday - not great
Mississippi Burning - good
Footloose (remake) - crap
Déjà vu - crap
Pulp Fiction - a classic
Stand By Me - quality
Boys n the Hood - decent
28 Days Later - so so
Capricorn One - never seen it
Spy Game - crap
Runaway Train (original) - never seen it
Australia - decent
American Werewolf in London - decent
The Getaway (original) - decent
State of Grace - crap
Manhunter - quality
True Romance - quality
Swimming Pool - never seen it
The Commitments - very good

taxi driver - a classic
apocalypse now - so so
come and see - never seen it
pretty village pretty flame - never seen it
stalker - never seen it
oldboy - good
deer hunter - quality
sonatine - never seen it
thin red line - crap
martyrs - never seen it
raging bull - a classic
the good the bad and the ugly - a classic
2001 - not a fan
la haine - never seen it
casino - decent
sympathy for mr vengance - never seen it
city of life and death - never seen it
hana bi - never seen it
paths of glory - never seen it
enter the void - never seen it
the simpsons - quality
bill and ted's excellent adventure - so so

Defo list 1 for me even if Good, The Bad and The Ugly is in my top 5 of all time. Though there's more I've not seen on list 2.

of course everyone loves ferris bueller, but if you put ferris bueller in, youve got to put weird science in, so...

There's some great movies in list 1, but list 2 is the better selection by a distance, imo.

List 1 imo

I would particularly like to thank Eddie for his detailed feedback

thank you eddie.

LIST 1

Star Wars - 9/10
Gladiator - 7/10
Point Break - 7/10
Déjà vu - 5/10
Pulp Fiction - 10/10
Stand By Me - 8/10
Boys n the Hood - 7/10
28 Days Later - 7/10
American Werewolf in London - 7/10
Manhunter - 7.5/10
True Romance - 7.5/10


LIST 2

taxi driver - 9/10
apocalypse now - 9/10
oldboy - 8/10
deer hunter - 6/10
raging bull - 8/10
the good the bad and the ugly - 9/10
casino - 8/10
the simpsons - 6/10
bill and ted's excellent adventure - 7/10

List 2 has better films but List 1 has more of them. It's a draw.

neither list is great really! Some classics in there but let down by some real weak ones....

By the way, if anyone wants to put in a list which they think can take on the winning list, please feel free to do so

The Simpsons movie being in the second list makes that list null and void. That movie is terrible