or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 32 comments are related to an article called:

Team GB and Ireland, greatest ever

Page 1 of 2

posted on 9/9/15

To hard to do.

I would come up with different players each time I remember someone else.

posted on 9/9/15



i feel let down VC... does this mean i beat you

posted on 9/9/15

Yes.

I am stuck at CB's that are English alone. Just from my time.

Moore, Charlton, Todd, McFarlane, Pallister, Adams, Rio, JT.

posted on 9/9/15

Goal keepers

Who do you pick out of Banks, Jennings, Clemence, Shilton, Seaman, Southall, etc.

posted on 9/9/15

Impossible to do imo.

England 11 alone it's impossible to pick, but one could be;

Banks
Pallister Ferdinand Moore Cole
Matthews Scholes Edwards Barnes
Charlton Rooney

posted on 9/9/15

this my man is a thinking mans article

posted on 9/9/15

^^^ Even with that, I'm looking at it and I'm convinced 80% of the team is wrong! Too many to pick from.

posted on 9/9/15

GK Goram
LB Cole
CB Hendry
CB Adams
RB Neville
CM Keane
CM Souness
LW Bale
RW Gazza
FW Best
FW Daglish

posted on 9/9/15

Maybe the way to do this, would be to pick an 11 from each nation, and then look at how you can merge them?

posted on 9/9/15

I went for Adams and Hendy because i wanted a some truly hard bassas in centre defence.

posted on 9/9/15

comment by Pedro Eliezer Rodríguez Ledesma (U19487)
posted 1 minute ago
^^^ Even with that, I'm looking at it and I'm convinced 80% of the team is wrong! Too many to pick from.
----------------------------------------------------------------------


especially pallister in there... and at RB

posted on 9/9/15

Pallister at RB????
Barnes
Charlton up front
Rooney, no Lineker
Scholes

posted on 9/9/15

Southall
Neville Hansen Moore Cole
Robson
Dalglish Charlton
Best Law Giggs

Very attack minded but would be pretty good at our scoring sides.

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 9/9/15

comment by Nicky Law's bald coot (U6025)
posted 4 minutes ago
GK Goram

---

That's cheating, you can't have 2 goalkeepers

posted on 9/9/15

*out scoring

posted on 9/9/15

Giggs

posted on 9/9/15

Bryan Robson, Roy Keane and Gazza would be a very good 3 man midfield.
But you'd want Charlton , Best and Brady in the team as well.

posted on 9/9/15

Before my time but lots of people say John Charles was the best Welsh player ever and one of the UK's best. A few years ago he was voted the best ever foreign player in Serie A, ahead of the likes of Maradona, Zidane and Platini (who were all fresher in the public memory).

posted on 9/9/15

Liam Brady. What a player that guy was.

Liam on the left, George on the right.

posted on 9/9/15

No idea about the best team but the following players would be hard for me to leave out even though they couldn't all play in the same team!

Charlton
Best
Law
Edwards
Giggs
Bale
Banks
Moore
Gazza
Robson
Keane


As a United fan I'd also be keen to include the likes of Ferdinand, Irwin and McGrath but there are just too many to choose from. I haven't even mentioned Adams, Pearce, Lineker, Shearer, Scholes, Becks, Dalglish, Rush, Hughes, etc..

It's hard enough picking the best of one nation let alone five!

posted on 9/9/15

Just trying to pick an inclusive team here and only players I've seen play in the flesh

.................Southall

Irwin ..... McGrath..... Hansen..... Cole

...... .... Keane ..... McAllister

...Best ...............................Brady

...........Keane.........Shearer


Subs: Jennings, Adams, Collins, Rush,
Manager: Ferguson

Robbie Keane makes it purely for his international record ( but he'd play off Shearer really well. )
Best, Jennings and Brady I only saw play for 7, 45 & 15 minutes respectively in charity matches - but I'm having them.

Certainly not necessarily the best from each nation or the best in their position, but for inclusivity and balance, I think it's a good side. Plus I'm Irish, so it'll have that slant.

Great article, could do this all day.

posted on 9/9/15

Bigirish

I bet you could also come up with a different eleven each time you think about it.

posted on 9/9/15

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 52 seconds ago
Bigirish

I bet you could also come up with a different eleven each time you think about it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm already half way through one, it's feckin addictive.

posted on 9/9/15

there are so many different variations, and all of them would be world class.

posted on 9/9/15

It also depends if you go for best XI players you can force into a team or picking a team that will form the strongest team formation wise.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment