Robbie definitely

totally different players...

I think every striker would want Beckham in midfield and every defender would want Keane

Keane did a few good songs and Posh can't really sing, so I would have to go with Keane.

Useless article. People will misinterpret the meaning of talent. Both gifted players

Neither of them could dab

Talentless mugs

Think Beckham wins the tattoo stakes hands down, not sure about his stupid hairstyles, bet he's gutted he never thought of putting a logo in there.

Keane.

Stretty says Keane, hands down.

I disgaree. Not many could deliver a dead ball like him or had his passing range.

So he could cross and pass. And was ok at free kicks.

Keane could defend, attack. Drive a team on like no other captain I've seen. Turned up in the biggest games.

And as respective players it's not even close who was better.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

The question is who was the better player. It's is who has the most talent (ability)

Whilst Keane had the drive and tenacity, I think Beckham had the greater ability

comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 1 minute ago
The question is who was the better player. It's is who has the most talent (ability)

Whilst Keane had the drive and tenacity, I think Beckham had the greater ability
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He didn't.

But you think paul Pogba is on par with Paul Scholes so that says everything.

Beckham had goood passing, good engine and a good but not great free kick.

Keane had virtually everything in the locker.

comment by Stretty - mr mourinho (U3123)
posted 5 minutes ago
So he could cross and pass. And was ok at free kicks.

Keane could defend, attack. Drive a team on like no other captain I've seen. Turned up in the biggest games.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So they both had talent then

No one said beckham didn't have talent. Just not as much as Keane.

Wtf is this new trend of point scoring about players that both played/play for our club?

Just enjoy the fact that we have had and continue to have great players at the club.

Drops mic.

comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - 2017 joy squids (U2958)
posted 17 seconds ago
Wtf is this new trend of point scoring about players that both played/play for our club?

Just enjoy the fact that we have had and continue to have great players at the club.

Drops mic.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Debating who is better is a perfectly fine thing to do.

Chucks mic at your head.

No, I think Pogba is further along than scholes was at 23 and that Pogba could surpass Scholes if he fulfills his potential.

I also think ability wise Beckham was better than Keane but Keane was the better player

comment by Reddevilsdouble - confident of a top 4 finish (U12215)
posted 51 seconds ago
No, I think Pogba is further along than scholes was at 23 and that Pogba could surpass Scholes if he fulfills his potential.

I also think ability wise Beckham was better than Keane but Keane was the better player
----------------------------------------------------------------------
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Great point Stretty

When the point is as funny as that there's not much else that can some up my feelings on the matter

Beckham is way over rated. He was a cog in a well oiled machine that SAF built. Without SAF he would have been yom cleverly

Beckham every day of the week,

Keane was a great player but Beckham had more talent

comment by Zlatanariyan (U19849)
posted 14 minutes ago
Beckham is way over rated. He was a cog in a well oiled machine that SAF built. Without SAF he would have been yom cleverly
----------------------------------------------------------------------

FFS