or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 48 comments are related to an article called:

Where was the VAR

Page 1 of 2

posted on 10/3/18


When you need it?

Clear penalties not given



===================

Corrected that for you........

posted on 10/3/18

Hand ball could have been given on another day. Which was the other?

posted on 10/3/18

Salah one was a pen, that’s it

posted on 10/3/18

Salahs one was half a dozen of one, 6 of another and contact started outside the box.

Now, everyone on me

They’ve got Salah, du du du du du
Oh mane mane, du du du du du
Even bobby firmino
But they still needed an own goal

They’ve got Salah, du du du du du
Oh mane mane, du du du du du
Even bobby firmino
But they still needed an own goal

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 10/3/18

Salah and handball were both pens, but both were at 2-0 so probably didn't make a difference to the result anyway. Nothing in the Mane one.

The Salah one is always a foul but because he is honest and stays on his feet there's no pen. If he did a Kane/Alli flop then he would probably get it, but that's the way it goes and I can understand why the ref doesn't give it.

Something refs need to look at it is giving pens to reward honest players in that situation but that's a debate for another day.

posted on 10/3/18

If he did a Kane/Alli flop - or a Mane one

posted on 10/3/18

not 1 of those was a penalty. sorry but if it was other way round and it was given in uniteds favour..you guys woul dhave been fuming! if any of them were a penalgty there would be 10 every game

posted on 10/3/18

If he did what he did against WBA then he would have got it.

posted on 10/3/18

Probably wouldn't have made a difference but how was Valencia not send off for his high foot?

posted on 10/3/18

Also had we had VAR and VVD scored it would’ve been disallowed since that thick twurp Milner can’t seem to legally take a corner (I.e ball touching the quadrant)

posted on 10/3/18

comment by The Welsh Xavi (U15412)
posted 48 seconds ago
Probably wouldn't have made a difference but how was Valencia not send off for his high foot?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cause he didnt touch him. And you boys were all bewildered by the mane sending off when he nearly took Edersons head off. Ridiculous.

posted on 10/3/18

Was Lovren booked in that game, seemed to spend 90 mins assaulting people

posted on 10/3/18

Play another record will ya, hiding behind pathetic excuses for not being good enough to deserve anything

posted on 10/3/18

The Mane one was not a clear pen. Yes Fellaini caught him first but Fellaini had positioned himself between the ball and Mane so you could argue Mane running into him was a foul on Fellaini. Mane would not have got possession or a clear run onto the ball if they hadn’t collided

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 10/3/18

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 2 minutes ago
Also had we had VAR and VVD scored it would’ve been disallowed since that thick twurp Milner can’t seem to legally take a corner (I.e ball touching the quadrant)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Scraping the barrell. Also ignores the fact VAR only reviews offsides, penalties and mistaken red cards. So no, it wouldn't have been disallowed. Nobody made a fuss at the time either.

posted on 10/3/18

comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 34 seconds ago
Was Lovren booked in that game, seemed to spend 90 mins assaulting people
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He should’ve had 2 yellows for those two tackles seconds apart, on Fellaini was it? Down by the left corner flag

posted on 10/3/18

comment by theiceone (U4646)
posted 4 minutes ago
not 1 of those was a penalty. sorry but if it was other way round and it was given in uniteds favour..you guys woul dhave been fuming! if any of them were a penalgty there would be 10 every game
----------------------------------------------------------------------

When G. Neville who hates LFC turns around and says they both should have been penalties to us you KNOW they both should have been penalties to us.

posted on 10/3/18

Have Liverpool ever not won a game where the ref is at fault?

posted on 10/3/18

comment by JonVeron (U6514)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 34 seconds ago
Was Lovren booked in that game, seemed to spend 90 mins assaulting people
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He should’ve had 2 yellows for those two tackles seconds apart, on Fellaini was it? Down by the left corner flag
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep, then the forearm smash on Mctominay's head

posted on 10/3/18

comment by Juan Matador (U17834)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by The Welsh Xavi (U15412)
posted 48 seconds ago
Probably wouldn't have made a difference but how was Valencia not send off for his high foot?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cause he didnt touch him. And you boys were all bewildered by the mane sending off when he nearly took Edersons head off. Ridiculous.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Caught his arm and it was dangerous play. Plus I never said mane shouldn't have been a red.

posted on 10/3/18

Carragher said they weren't penalties against Utd, you know they aren't penalties

posted on 10/3/18

Bizarrely Klopp seems incensed about the mane fellaini one.

That one looked like mane fouled Fella

posted on 10/3/18

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 7 minutes ago
Also had we had VAR and VVD scored it would’ve been disallowed since that thick twurp Milner can’t seem to legally take a corner (I.e ball touching the quadrant)
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Fortunately Milner ISN'T such a thick twurp that he thinks the ball has to be touching the quadrant. He knows that the edge of the ball has to be hanging over the edge of the line of the quadrant.

posted on 10/3/18

comment by Bake 'em away toys (U7303)
posted 2 minutes ago
Have Liverpool ever not won a game where the ref is at fault?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Many times and i'm sure your fans brought the subject up at the time but today we're discussing this game

posted on 10/3/18

I thought the fellaini one was a pen but the others I didn't. lets be honest Liverpool need a freak goal to get going so you cant blame the ref.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment