Selling Pogba would be a stupid decision, and would send out all the wrong messages

Because when those players return from injury he’d just get benched again. He’s better off getting regular game time somewhere else. It’s common sense

Very soon the boring one is going to come with his whinging

Maybe he wouldn’t get benched if he proved him self in those game? I thought that’s how it worked?

Do people see Jose getting rid of Valencia without being forced to with undeniable talent or do we have to put up with his pub football style crosses into the box for another 3 seasons?

Well what if he doesn’t prove himself? Waste a season or half a season of development because he didn’t prove himself? Going on loan and getting better at a lower pressure club than Manchester United is best.

Stupidity from the club. We already have two right backs out of action. Unsure who this benefits.

comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 10 minutes ago
Very soon the boring one is going to come with his whinging
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Only one person whinging here

comment by Erik (U21750)

posted 10 minutes ago

Well what if he doesn’t prove himself? Waste a season or half a season of development because he didn’t prove himself? Going on loan and getting better at a lower pressure club than Manchester United is best.
----------

He could still go on loan.

He wasn’t going to play ahead of Tony so I think a loan spell at a good level where he can play week in week out is more beneficial. Too many fans seem to think our young players are ready when they’re unlikely to get regular game time.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Pogba going makes sense.

He's been poor for us, the league doesn't suit him.

Spain will. We get a good price and I'm all for this.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

While Pogba has been slightly disappointing so far we’d be mad to sell him now.

I think SMS at Lazio would be a good replacement

I actually think we have enough without Pogba. But ultimately if he doesn’t want to be at the club (if) then what do we have to lose by selling him.

Imagine Barca giving us say, £50 million and Dembele for him?

Ffs

comment by Nobb 🇦🇺🇪🇸 (U21234)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think SMS at Lazio would be a good replacement

I actually think we have enough without Pogba. But ultimately if he doesn’t want to be at the club (if) then what do we have to lose by selling him.

Imagine Barca giving us say, £50 million and Dembele for him?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah great. And have a midfield 3 of an ageing Matic, Fred and either Herrera or Fellaini.
You really do come up with the sheitest ideas

comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Nobb 🇦🇺🇪🇸 (U21234)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think SMS at Lazio would be a good replacement

I actually think we have enough without Pogba. But ultimately if he doesn’t want to be at the club (if) then what do we have to lose by selling him.

Imagine Barca giving us say, £50 million and Dembele for him?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah great. And have a midfield 3 of an ageing Matic, Fred and either Herrera or Fellaini.
You really do come up with the sheitest ideas
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Or a midfield of Matic, Pereira and Fred. What’s wrong with Herrera? Surely they have to be better options than a potentially sulky Pogba? And I only want him sold if he is going to sulk

If he wants to stay and kick in then obv I want him to stay

comment by Nobb 🇦🇺🇪🇸 (U21234)
posted 12 seconds ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Nobb 🇦🇺🇪🇸 (U21234)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think SMS at Lazio would be a good replacement

I actually think we have enough without Pogba. But ultimately if he doesn’t want to be at the club (if) then what do we have to lose by selling him.

Imagine Barca giving us say, £50 million and Dembele for him?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah great. And have a midfield 3 of an ageing Matic, Fred and either Herrera or Fellaini.
You really do come up with the sheitest ideas
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Or a midfield of Matic, Pereira and Fred. What’s wrong with Herrera? Surely they have to be better options than a potentially sulky Pogba? And I only want him sold if he is going to sulk

If he wants to stay and kick in then obv I want him to stay
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would be happy with Perreira but he isn't going to play every game under Jose and a replacement for Pogba? No chance. Likewise herrera who i like isn't on Pogbas level.
Pogba even not at his best still is by far and away our best creator of chances. Letting him go this late in a window would be criminal

Robb, you've gone from saying pereira is too raw, and should be loaned out, to having him replace Pogba. You do make me laugh.

comment by Elvis (U7425)
posted 1 minute ago
Robb, you've gone from saying pereira is too raw, and should be loaned out, to having him replace Pogba. You do make me laugh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

When did I say he was too raw? I want him to stay and think he was excellent at Valencia. If he wants to be loaned out then fair enough - but if Pogba was to go I’d be fine with him playing as I feel he’s ready for a chance

I defended Pogba more than anyone on here and want him to stay

But if (and I’m saying if) he wants to go then he should go

News today that Valencia might even be fit for the second game of the season

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Nobb 🇦🇺🇪🇸 (U21234)

posted 10 minutes ago

comment by Elvis (U7425) 
posted 1 minute ago
Robb, you've gone from saying pereira is too raw, and should be loaned out, to having him replace Pogba. You do make me laugh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

When did I say he was too raw? 
-------

Just a few days ago.