or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 29 comments are related to an article called:

Kalvin Phillips

Page 1 of 2

posted on 2/7/19



morning Siaz - chill man, the sun is shining

posted on 2/7/19

Someone is overdue a a chug.

comment by RobLUFC (U5692)

posted on 2/7/19

Time to change your user name.it's so last season.

posted on 2/7/19

I think it’s down to Phillips excelling under Bielsa, and the fact he’s still the manager.

We’ve proven again and again that we don’t replace key players well at all.

The fee becomes irrelevant if we fail to improve the squad.

comment by Jonty (U4614)

posted on 2/7/19

comment by The Hayemaker (U14625)
posted 21 seconds ago
I think it’s down to Phillips excelling under Bielsa, and the fact he’s still the manager.

We’ve proven again and again that we don’t replace key players well at all.

The fee becomes irrelevant if we fail to improve the squad.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Completely agree. Every player has their price, but if we’re selling just to get cheap players in and pay AR rent for ER then there is a problem.

comment by Stoopo (U4707)

posted on 2/7/19

See the Clarke deal is done and he’s coming back on loan as expected.

comment by Mattyp (U8926)

posted on 2/7/19

It's not hypocritical to change your opinion on someone you know nothing buffoon.

I mean seriously do you even know what being a hypocrite means, or are you as stupid as this thread.

Phillips before Bielsa came along was a poor player. However Bielsa has improved him 50 fold and now as a result he is a vital cog in our team and one which we should endeavour to keep.

Changing you opinion does not make you a hypocrite

Jesus wept, I pity you for coming up with a thread as stupid as this.

posted on 2/7/19

Jesus wept

----------

not heard that phrase for ages

comment by NJS (U8272)

posted on 2/7/19

^ ^ ^
What since the dark ages...you must be a really old man?!

Bielsa did improve Phillips cos the season before the last one he wouldn't even head the 🏀 he made lame efforts to make it look he was making an attempt...this season someone must have had a word in his ear cos he made significant improvement.
It's debatable though how many points he cost the team this season after his sending off against Villa was it? Team playing well in control, he gets sent off and we lose 4 - 1 then a few weeks suspension, defence rejigged, stability gone, cue inconsistency, losing points...though not blaming him totally, others were very inconsistent after the New Year...if 20m for Phillips can be got sell him.

comment by Batty (U4664)

posted on 2/7/19

I've said this before, KP was always a very good player.
It needed the right coach to bring that player to the first XI.

Redders tabbed Kalvin for stardom a long time back.
Bielsa (the fooking genius that he is) saw KP's potential,
and best position. Now we have Kalvin Pirlo.

I still personally don't want to sell him. But, again I get the draw (and sense) of capitalizing on a 20mill bid.

posted on 2/7/19

comment by NJS (U8272)
posted 20 minutes ago

^ ^ ^
What since the dark ages...you must be a really old man?!

--------------

yeah, my Dad used to say that a lot - he heard it on the wireless I think

posted on 2/7/19

what a mess of an article.
and as long as you have that useless player in your username everything you write looks stupid.

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Batty (U4664)
posted 17 minutes ago
I've said this before, KP was always a very good player.
It needed the right coach to bring that player to the first XI.

Redders tabbed Kalvin for stardom a long time back.
Bielsa (the fooking genius that he is) saw KP's potential,
and best position. Now we have Kalvin Pirlo.

I still personally don't want to sell him. But, again I get the draw (and sense) of capitalizing on a 20mill bid.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yep agreed. I thought there was a good player there, just needed better coaching & players around him.

Wasn’t the best, but I did think he had something about him.

But, £20m if spent wisely (big if!), could replace him with 3 at least quality additions.

posted on 2/7/19

comment by montleeds (U18330)
posted 24 minutes ago

what a mess of an article.
and as long as you have that useless player in your username everything you write looks stupid.

-----------------

Why is it a mess? I've used Saiz's name to defend him from the ridiculous criticism he gets on this board from idiots like you.

comment by Batty (U4664)

posted on 2/7/19

Must admit, I liked Saiz. Wouldn't be opposed
to having him back. IF MB wanted him.

posted on 2/7/19

Mattyp, contradictory / hypocrite call it what you like, it's what you are and just show's your lack of judgement.

posted on 2/7/19

Batty, anyone who knows anything about football knows he is a good player.

posted on 2/7/19

KP is okay, some on here think he’s fantastic, he’s not. Sell for silly money.

comment by AZA (U5000)

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 34 minutes ago
Mattyp, contradictory / hypocrite call it what you like, it's what you are and just show's your lack of judgement.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Lack of judgement....

Phillips was a liability, constantly losing his head and turning in poor performances.

If you mean I have changed my mind about him due to the fact we have a WORLD CLASS coach to teach him then yes, I have.

I wouldn’t have imaging we’d get anything other than a Hockaday or at best another Monk. Then the future Messiah of Leeds walks through the door to not only drag this city and club forwards but to revitalise / improve the future careers of the squad before him.

Phillips was shet, now he is not.

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 1 hour, 31 minutes ago
comment by montleeds (U18330)
posted 24 minutes ago

what a mess of an article.
and as long as you have that useless player in your username everything you write looks stupid.

-----------------

Why is it a mess? I've used Saiz's name to defend him from the ridiculous criticism he gets on this board from idiots like you.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
saiz has kicked around the lower leagues without much success and then quit halfway through a season that he did nothing of note in.
a few simple tricks impress some people but most need some kind of end product to justify a place in the team. hope your wish doesn't come true and this hothead never plays for leeds again.

comment by Mattyp (U8926)

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)

posted 3 hours, 9 minutes ago

Mattyp, contradictory / hypocrite call it what you like, it's what you are and just show's your lack of judgement.

---------

Is english your first language?

I ask cause if it is you are so stupid that at this stage Jesus isint weeping he is dry heave crying.

It's neither of those things is it you moron.

It's not contradictory to change your mind and want to keep a player after he improves massively.

I was 100% serious earlier when I said I pity you.

Cause quite frankly this thread is so embarrassing it's not even funny.

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Mattyp (U8926)
posted on 31/7/18

Anyone see anyone paying 7 million for Phillips?

“Says it all.”

----------------

Guilty as charged!

posted on 2/7/19

comment by AZA (U5000)
posted on 31/7/18

They pick Phillips and we get overrun, rinse, repeat.

-----------------

Guilty, take him down!

comment by Mattyp (U8926)

posted on 2/7/19

and?

Talk about clutching at straws. You pluck a comment from a year ago before he improved massively.

So I changed my mind on a player and decided he should be kept after he improved massively over a long period of time

woopdedo.

Do you actually think this is some sort of gotcha?

Cause if you do then that's just pathetic.

Ive hardly been silent on how good he has played this year and that improvement, and our poor record in the transfer market mean I'd rather we keep him.

comment by AZA (U5000)

posted on 2/7/19

comment by Wish we had Saiz (U21886)
posted 4 hours, 1 minute ago
comment by AZA (U5000)
posted on 31/7/18

They pick Phillips and we get overrun, rinse, repeat.

-----------------

Guilty, take him down!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think you’re just bored, maybe your sister has gone out.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment