Is the discussion about it on the thread below not good enough?
Far too sensible and anyway there would be arguments about how unbiased the 3 person panel is
I think it's clear that the compliance system just isn't working right
---------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think it's clear which is part of the problem. It might be but we just don't know it?
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 5 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No 100% not
Indeed, as has been said since the 20s, justice should not just be done but also be seen to be done.
Is this not exactly what Gordon Smith called for years ago to cut out simulation. All game incidents reviewed on a Monday morning. Or I suppose if someone could invent a system whereby the incidents were looked at and dealt with in real time, that would be better.
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 52 minutes ago
Is the discussion about it on the thread below not good enough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My apologies for not seeing the thread below regards this
Still don't see it to be honest
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 43 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never really understood this kind of thinking to be honest mate
If refs are making mistakes, there should be means to rectify them and improve
Simply going "och it happens" does nothing to improve things....thing like the Henry handball against Ireland for instance can cost a country huge sums of money for instance...all because a red has made a huge fck up
Simply can't allow such things to happen in this day and age, we have the technology now...use it
comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 43 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never really understood this kind of thinking to be honest mate
If refs are making mistakes, there should be means to rectify them and improve
Simply going "och it happens" does nothing to improve things....thing like the Henry handball against Ireland for instance can cost a country huge sums of money for instance...all because a red has made a huge fck up
Simply can't allow such things to happen in this day and age, we have the technology now...use it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
By all means punish keech refs for keech decisions.
Seems to me that is what is overlooked here.
All the focus on the players - very little on the referee.
Wrong.
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would happily have var. Still don't get why some don't like it.
I do think the offside thing feels like it needs clarity. I think an armpit or part of your torso can get you offside.
Leg or heid for me. Ridiculous handball rules need sorted too. Overall though it's a great thing.
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
In making the handball easier to adjudicate they've made some incidents seem unduly unfair.
comment by super phoenix rangers - comments on this forum are not mine but a fictionalised version loosely based on someone similar to me (U14864)
posted 40 seconds ago
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Play of the month / Play for today back in the 60s / early 70s - would invariably be some gratuitous skud. There only was 3 channels and no remote controls so it was harder for your parents to hastily turn it over - brilliant!
Watching teenage superstars.
The Glasgow alt music scene in the 80's
For all you diddly Dee types who also like young Irish ladies there is something called Celtic woman
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by super phoenix rangers - comments on this forum are not mine but a fictionalised version loosely based on someone similar to me (U14864)
posted 40 seconds ago
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Play of the month / Play for today back in the 60s / early 70s - would invariably be some gratuitous skud. There only was 3 channels and no remote controls so it was harder for your parents to hastily turn it over - brilliant!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Always enjoyed the plays on the beeb back then, Poor Cow was a huge disappointment though.
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR is the worst thing to happen to football
https://mobile.twitter.com/allthatchas/status/1357751795720855557?s=21
Knew it.
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 9 hours, 19 minutes ago
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR is the worst thing to happen to football
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This ^
VAR in its current incarnation in the Premier League, is far from perfect
But for me, the principal is correct, they just have to tweak the system
You very rarely hear anyone from rugby saying that the TMO is a $hite idea, they’ve been using it for 20 years and it works
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Sign in if you want to comment
Compliance System
Page 1 of 4
posted on 5/2/21
Is the discussion about it on the thread below not good enough?
posted on 5/2/21
Far too sensible and anyway there would be arguments about how unbiased the 3 person panel is
posted on 5/2/21
I think it's clear that the compliance system just isn't working right
---------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think it's clear which is part of the problem. It might be but we just don't know it?
posted on 5/2/21
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
posted on 5/2/21
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 5 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No 100% not
posted on 5/2/21
Indeed, as has been said since the 20s, justice should not just be done but also be seen to be done.
posted on 5/2/21
Is this not exactly what Gordon Smith called for years ago to cut out simulation. All game incidents reviewed on a Monday morning. Or I suppose if someone could invent a system whereby the incidents were looked at and dealt with in real time, that would be better.
posted on 5/2/21
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 52 minutes ago
Is the discussion about it on the thread below not good enough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My apologies for not seeing the thread below regards this
Still don't see it to be honest
posted on 5/2/21
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 43 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never really understood this kind of thinking to be honest mate
If refs are making mistakes, there should be means to rectify them and improve
Simply going "och it happens" does nothing to improve things....thing like the Henry handball against Ireland for instance can cost a country huge sums of money for instance...all because a red has made a huge fck up
Simply can't allow such things to happen in this day and age, we have the technology now...use it
posted on 5/2/21
comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 43 minutes ago
This over analysis of every ref decision is killing the spirit of football imo.
We need less reviews and get back to just getting on with taking original ref calls on the chin.
Football fans have become such babies and all this stuff does is give our authorities another chance to showcase their incompetency.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I've never really understood this kind of thinking to be honest mate
If refs are making mistakes, there should be means to rectify them and improve
Simply going "och it happens" does nothing to improve things....thing like the Henry handball against Ireland for instance can cost a country huge sums of money for instance...all because a red has made a huge fck up
Simply can't allow such things to happen in this day and age, we have the technology now...use it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
By all means punish keech refs for keech decisions.
Seems to me that is what is overlooked here.
All the focus on the players - very little on the referee.
Wrong.
posted on 5/2/21
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
posted on 5/2/21
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
posted on 5/2/21
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would happily have var. Still don't get why some don't like it.
I do think the offside thing feels like it needs clarity. I think an armpit or part of your torso can get you offside.
Leg or heid for me. Ridiculous handball rules need sorted too. Overall though it's a great thing.
posted on 5/2/21
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
posted on 5/2/21
In making the handball easier to adjudicate they've made some incidents seem unduly unfair.
posted on 5/2/21
comment by super phoenix rangers - comments on this forum are not mine but a fictionalised version loosely based on someone similar to me (U14864)
posted 40 seconds ago
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Play of the month / Play for today back in the 60s / early 70s - would invariably be some gratuitous skud. There only was 3 channels and no remote controls so it was harder for your parents to hastily turn it over - brilliant!
posted on 5/2/21
Watching teenage superstars.
The Glasgow alt music scene in the 80's
posted on 5/2/21
For all you diddly Dee types who also like young Irish ladies there is something called Celtic woman
posted on 5/2/21
And Metallica s&m 2
posted on 5/2/21
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 28 minutes ago
comment by super phoenix rangers - comments on this forum are not mine but a fictionalised version loosely based on someone similar to me (U14864)
posted 40 seconds ago
Unrelated but some of the stuff on sky arts is brilliant
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Play of the month / Play for today back in the 60s / early 70s - would invariably be some gratuitous skud. There only was 3 channels and no remote controls so it was harder for your parents to hastily turn it over - brilliant!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Always enjoyed the plays on the beeb back then, Poor Cow was a huge disappointment though.
posted on 5/2/21
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR is the worst thing to happen to football
posted on 5/2/21
https://mobile.twitter.com/allthatchas/status/1357751795720855557?s=21
Knew it.
posted on 6/2/21
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 9 hours, 19 minutes ago
comment by The Duke (U10059)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by Coisty - Official (U12077)
posted 47 minutes ago
As for the Henry decision.
No amount of reviews can alter that nor prevent it from happening again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR would have disallowed it
----------------------------------------------------------------------
VAR is the worst thing to happen to football
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This ^
posted on 6/2/21
VAR in its current incarnation in the Premier League, is far from perfect
But for me, the principal is correct, they just have to tweak the system
You very rarely hear anyone from rugby saying that the TMO is a $hite idea, they’ve been using it for 20 years and it works
posted on 6/2/21
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Page 1 of 4