I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
Toss up between Martinez and Rashford for POTS, for me.
Both have been absolutely key to our successes this season.
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 8 minutes ago
I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I probably have been a little soft but we have just finished 3rd and won a cup. The ratings reflect a good season.
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 9 minutes ago
Toss up between Martinez and Rashford for POTS, for me.
Both have been absolutely key to our successes this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It is close, no doubt, but my opinion is Lissa has been a monster this season. Absolute beast
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And I may be being a little harsh on him.
Considering his strengths and weaknesses as a player, he’s done pretty well really this season. We know he isn’t that progressive, ball-playing sweeper keeper that we all want to see replace him; but he was never going to be able to magically transform himself into such at this stage in his career.
Given that the vast majority of his errors and poorer plays have resulted directly from him being asked to do a job he just isn’t suited to or comfortable with, I think he’s been a little harshly judged by some at times this season.
De gea the same as rashford?
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And I may be being a little harsh on him.
Considering his strengths and weaknesses as a player, he’s done pretty well really this season. We know he isn’t that progressive, ball-playing sweeper keeper that we all want to see replace him; but he was never going to be able to magically transform himself into such at this stage in his career.
Given that the vast majority of his errors and poorer plays have resulted directly from him being asked to do a job he just isn’t suited to or comfortable with, I think he’s been a little harshly judged by some at times this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 19 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 8 minutes ago
I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I probably have been a little soft but we have just finished 3rd and won a cup. The ratings reflect a good season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah fair enough mate.
Any of Shaw, Martinez, Casemiro or Rashford would be good calls for PoTS...
For me Rashford!
I'd have Fred and Pellistri a point higher.
Fred has improved,bumpily, and Pellistri has done well when given a chance.
comment by manusince52 (U9692)
posted 5 minutes ago
I'd have Fred and Pellistri a point higher.
Fred has improved,bumpily, and Pellistri has done well when given a chance.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe on Fred but Pellistri just hasnt played enough unfortunately
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
comment by RB&W - Whiteside has done it again (U21434)
posted 15 minutes ago
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They have but our defence also deserves a shout; much improved, lots of clean sheets
DDG - 7.5
AWB - 7
DALOT -7
VARANE - 8
MARTINEZ 8.5
LINDELOF - 7
MAGUIRE - 5
SHAW - 8
MALACIA -6.5
CASEMIRO - 8
FRED - 6.5
MCTOM - 6.5
SABITZER - 7
ERIKSEN - 7
FERNANDES - 8
RASHFORD - 8
GARNACHO - 7
SANCHO - 6.5
ANTONY - 7
PELLISTRI - 6
MARTIAL - 6
WEGHORST - 6
DDG 6.5
AWB 7
Dalot 6
Varane 8
Martinez 8
Lindelof 7
Shaw 8
Malacia 4
Maguire 4
Casemiro 8.5
Eriksen 6.5
Bruno 7.5
Fred 6.5
Mctom 5
Sabitzer 6
Sancho 6
Antony 6
Garnacho 6.5
Weggy 0
Martial 6
Rashford 8
DDG 6.5
AWB 7
Dalot 6
Varane 8
Martinez 8.5
Lindelof 7
Shaw 8
Malacia 5
Maguire 4
Casemiro 8
Eriksen 6.5
Bruno 7.5
Fred 6.5
Mctom 5
Sabitzer 6
Sancho 6
Antony 6
Garnacho 6.5
Weggy 4
Martial 6.5
Rashford 8
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 3 hours, 48 minutes ago
comment by RB&W - Whiteside has done it again (U21434)
posted 15 minutes ago
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They have but our defence also deserves a shout; much improved, lots of clean sheets
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They are all good players without Maguire. Awb and Lindelof included
Lindelöf early season - 6 - late season - 8. A tale of two seasons, almost. When he plays with Maguire - he's a 6 and when paired with Varane, an 8. Says a lot about what a liability The Harry is.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
comment by Admin1 (U1)
posted 25 minutes ago
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looks like Wesley Schnider
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Admin1 (U1)
posted 25 minutes ago
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looks like Wesley Schnider
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I was going to say Chris Wilder, but fack knows what he’d be doing signing that ball
Schneiders signature looks different on Google.
Sign in if you want to comment
Player ratings for the Season
Page 1 of 2
posted on 29/5/23
I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
posted on 29/5/23
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
posted on 29/5/23
Toss up between Martinez and Rashford for POTS, for me.
Both have been absolutely key to our successes this season.
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 8 minutes ago
I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I probably have been a little soft but we have just finished 3rd and won a cup. The ratings reflect a good season.
posted on 29/5/23
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
posted on 29/5/23
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 9 minutes ago
Toss up between Martinez and Rashford for POTS, for me.
Both have been absolutely key to our successes this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It is close, no doubt, but my opinion is Lissa has been a monster this season. Absolute beast
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And I may be being a little harsh on him.
Considering his strengths and weaknesses as a player, he’s done pretty well really this season. We know he isn’t that progressive, ball-playing sweeper keeper that we all want to see replace him; but he was never going to be able to magically transform himself into such at this stage in his career.
Given that the vast majority of his errors and poorer plays have resulted directly from him being asked to do a job he just isn’t suited to or comfortable with, I think he’s been a little harshly judged by some at times this season.
posted on 29/5/23
De gea the same as rashford?
posted on 29/5/23
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by rosso says the time has come to unlock the unlimited Pote-ntial of the Fernançalvemiro triumvirate (U17054)
posted 8 minutes ago
Pretty good assessment, I’d say
I’d only definitely change:
De Gea 7/10 (issues with his distribution, errors earlier in the season, and, still, pretty poor aerially and coming off his line)
Varane 8/10
Bruno 8/10 (has created half of our chances, leading the PL, and we just don’t ever look like scoring when he isn’t on the pitch)
Rashford 9/10 (incredible goalscoring return across competitions, and we’d have been in serious, serious shiiiiit without his consistent contributions both off the left and up top)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's, i can accept those rating changes. I only gave DDG an 8 because he won the golden glove. Im still of the opinion we need a more progressive keeper but to achieve that in this season is very good from him
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And I may be being a little harsh on him.
Considering his strengths and weaknesses as a player, he’s done pretty well really this season. We know he isn’t that progressive, ball-playing sweeper keeper that we all want to see replace him; but he was never going to be able to magically transform himself into such at this stage in his career.
Given that the vast majority of his errors and poorer plays have resulted directly from him being asked to do a job he just isn’t suited to or comfortable with, I think he’s been a little harshly judged by some at times this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 19 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 8 minutes ago
I think you’ve been soft on some tbh
Maguire is worse than a 5
Garnacho hasn’t had an 8/10 season, very exciting and looking forward to watching him again next season but he didn’t have as good a season as Shaw & Rashford
Antony I think was a 6 not a 7
Martial was a 5
Sancho was a 5
McTom was a 5
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I probably have been a little soft but we have just finished 3rd and won a cup. The ratings reflect a good season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah fair enough mate.
posted on 29/5/23
Any of Shaw, Martinez, Casemiro or Rashford would be good calls for PoTS...
For me Rashford!
posted on 29/5/23
I'd have Fred and Pellistri a point higher.
Fred has improved,bumpily, and Pellistri has done well when given a chance.
posted on 29/5/23
comment by manusince52 (U9692)
posted 5 minutes ago
I'd have Fred and Pellistri a point higher.
Fred has improved,bumpily, and Pellistri has done well when given a chance.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe on Fred but Pellistri just hasnt played enough unfortunately
posted on 29/5/23
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
posted on 29/5/23
comment by RB&W - Whiteside has done it again (U21434)
posted 15 minutes ago
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They have but our defence also deserves a shout; much improved, lots of clean sheets
posted on 29/5/23
DDG - 7.5
AWB - 7
DALOT -7
VARANE - 8
MARTINEZ 8.5
LINDELOF - 7
MAGUIRE - 5
SHAW - 8
MALACIA -6.5
CASEMIRO - 8
FRED - 6.5
MCTOM - 6.5
SABITZER - 7
ERIKSEN - 7
FERNANDES - 8
RASHFORD - 8
GARNACHO - 7
SANCHO - 6.5
ANTONY - 7
PELLISTRI - 6
MARTIAL - 6
WEGHORST - 6
posted on 29/5/23
DDG 6.5
AWB 7
Dalot 6
Varane 8
Martinez 8
Lindelof 7
Shaw 8
Malacia 4
Maguire 4
Casemiro 8.5
Eriksen 6.5
Bruno 7.5
Fred 6.5
Mctom 5
Sabitzer 6
Sancho 6
Antony 6
Garnacho 6.5
Weggy 0
Martial 6
Rashford 8
posted on 29/5/23
DDG 6.5
AWB 7
Dalot 6
Varane 8
Martinez 8.5
Lindelof 7
Shaw 8
Malacia 5
Maguire 4
Casemiro 8
Eriksen 6.5
Bruno 7.5
Fred 6.5
Mctom 5
Sabitzer 6
Sancho 6
Antony 6
Garnacho 6.5
Weggy 4
Martial 6.5
Rashford 8
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 3 hours, 48 minutes ago
comment by RB&W - Whiteside has done it again (U21434)
posted 15 minutes ago
Bruno and Rashy have carried us this season.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They have but our defence also deserves a shout; much improved, lots of clean sheets
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They are all good players without Maguire. Awb and Lindelof included
posted on 29/5/23
Lindelöf early season - 6 - late season - 8. A tale of two seasons, almost. When he plays with Maguire - he's a 6 and when paired with Varane, an 8. Says a lot about what a liability The Harry is.
posted on 29/5/23
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 29/5/23
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Admin1 (U1)
posted 25 minutes ago
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looks like Wesley Schnider
posted on 29/5/23
comment by Olorin (U22733)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Admin1 (U1)
posted 25 minutes ago
Found an old football. Ball made 2003
Any idea the signature
https://postimg.cc/68Twc6K2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Looks like Wesley Schnider
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I was going to say Chris Wilder, but fack knows what he’d be doing signing that ball
posted on 29/5/23
Schneiders signature looks different on Google.
Page 1 of 2