Partey yes, no on the other 2
comment by Vladimikel Artutin - committing war crimes against football since 2019 (U18355)
posted 41 minutes ago
Partey yes, no on the other 2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This
Partey - yes.
Gabriel - Still has a glaring weakness with his passing. But we don't have a player who is as passionate and aggressive, which is sometimes necessary in difficult matches. Would need a huge bid and a replacement.
ESR - Not until he is given more chances. He has the ability to score from ACM and you don't give away those type of players till you are damn sure their development has stalled.
Partey yes but i wouldnt want to sell ESR and Gabriel
I think if an offer comes in for Partey in Jan we should and would take it. Don't think he'll get many minutes either way but I would worry if Rice got injured we would be facked without him and Partey.
Gabs no chance, never been a big as cheerleader of his as some others but no doubt he is a decent enough player.
ESR not unless it was a silly offer, and not to a rival. He is 23 now though and needs to be playing regularly otherwise his career is going to go down the drain.
Partey - yes sell as soon as possible. Still class player when fit but there you go.....
ESR - no way.
Gabriel - wasnt his big fan of him when he moved from City. As long as we dont have a replacement for him we shouldnt sell him.
comment by Gunnerthru (U6675)
posted 3 minutes ago
Partey - yes sell as soon as possible. Still class player when fit but there you go.....
ESR - no way.
Gabriel - wasnt his big fan of him when he moved from City. As long as we dont have a replacement for him we shouldnt sell him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he mean Gabriel Magalhaes
ESR isnt on huge wages, is good enough to fill in for players outwith the first 11 and is a homegrown player.
No chance Arteta will want him to go.
I'd sell DJs bawls for a cheese toastie
Partey yes, ESR no and Gabi Martinelli hell no.
Partey - probably but this depends on price
ESR - defo not
Gabriel - defo not
Havertz - yes for a packet of crisps and a sticky jazz mag
Nelson - yes - if he hasn't broken thru now he never will
Eddie - will always be a reserve. Bit more hench but still only a 1 in 3 striker
Raya - prefer Ramsdale so wouldn't keep him after his loan
Vieira - in 2 minds and would keep as long as he gets game time and continues to improve
Jesus - love his energy but not a natural finisher and if we can get better we should.
So the general consensus is Partey out the other two stay.
Yeah, partey should go - we do miss what he brings to the team but our results are still largely good. Get what you can for him, invest it into somebody who is just as good a passer and mover as he is. Time to move on from him.
The other 2 are more difficult: wouldn't say no if huge offers came in for either. But I can see ESR easily getting plenty of minutes in midfield for us. He did start over Vieira on the weekend.
Gabriel is too good not to be starting, so if he finds himself on the bench, we should get the most we can for him.
The big problem with Gabriel is who you'd get to replace him with. Timber is basically untested, and there isn't a lot out there that is guaranteed to work well with Saliba - who, given his record, may need cover anyway.
I wouldn't want to see ESR go but he doesn't look the same as he did. I think it would hinge on him getting more game time and seeing how he goes.
Party - Get a good offer and wave goodbye. He isn't irreplaceable and will miss to much game time through the ANC alone. Put a halfway decent midfield around Rice and we wouldn't even miss him.
Would give Kiwoir a run in the team tbh. He filled in well last season and has done pretty well every time he has played this season. Never really had a run with Saliba, and is the better passer Arteta wants that side of the defence.
Judging by early season Timber was here to replace Gabriel in the XI, although Zinnys absence may have forced that a bit.
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Would you sell...
Page 1 of 1
posted on 1/11/23
Partey yes, no on the other 2
posted on 1/11/23
comment by Vladimikel Artutin - committing war crimes against football since 2019 (U18355)
posted 41 minutes ago
Partey yes, no on the other 2
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This
posted on 1/11/23
Partey - yes.
Gabriel - Still has a glaring weakness with his passing. But we don't have a player who is as passionate and aggressive, which is sometimes necessary in difficult matches. Would need a huge bid and a replacement.
ESR - Not until he is given more chances. He has the ability to score from ACM and you don't give away those type of players till you are damn sure their development has stalled.
posted on 1/11/23
Partey yes but i wouldnt want to sell ESR and Gabriel
posted on 1/11/23
I think if an offer comes in for Partey in Jan we should and would take it. Don't think he'll get many minutes either way but I would worry if Rice got injured we would be facked without him and Partey.
Gabs no chance, never been a big as cheerleader of his as some others but no doubt he is a decent enough player.
ESR not unless it was a silly offer, and not to a rival. He is 23 now though and needs to be playing regularly otherwise his career is going to go down the drain.
posted on 1/11/23
Partey - yes sell as soon as possible. Still class player when fit but there you go.....
ESR - no way.
Gabriel - wasnt his big fan of him when he moved from City. As long as we dont have a replacement for him we shouldnt sell him.
posted on 1/11/23
comment by Gunnerthru (U6675)
posted 3 minutes ago
Partey - yes sell as soon as possible. Still class player when fit but there you go.....
ESR - no way.
Gabriel - wasnt his big fan of him when he moved from City. As long as we dont have a replacement for him we shouldnt sell him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think he mean Gabriel Magalhaes
posted on 1/11/23
ESR isnt on huge wages, is good enough to fill in for players outwith the first 11 and is a homegrown player.
No chance Arteta will want him to go.
posted on 1/11/23
I'd sell DJs bawls for a cheese toastie
posted on 1/11/23
Partey yes, ESR no and Gabi Martinelli hell no.
posted on 1/11/23
Havertz
you're welcome
posted on 1/11/23
Partey - probably but this depends on price
ESR - defo not
Gabriel - defo not
Havertz - yes for a packet of crisps and a sticky jazz mag
Nelson - yes - if he hasn't broken thru now he never will
Eddie - will always be a reserve. Bit more hench but still only a 1 in 3 striker
Raya - prefer Ramsdale so wouldn't keep him after his loan
Vieira - in 2 minds and would keep as long as he gets game time and continues to improve
Jesus - love his energy but not a natural finisher and if we can get better we should.
posted on 1/11/23
So the general consensus is Partey out the other two stay.
posted on 1/11/23
Yeah, partey should go - we do miss what he brings to the team but our results are still largely good. Get what you can for him, invest it into somebody who is just as good a passer and mover as he is. Time to move on from him.
The other 2 are more difficult: wouldn't say no if huge offers came in for either. But I can see ESR easily getting plenty of minutes in midfield for us. He did start over Vieira on the weekend.
Gabriel is too good not to be starting, so if he finds himself on the bench, we should get the most we can for him.
posted on 2/11/23
The big problem with Gabriel is who you'd get to replace him with. Timber is basically untested, and there isn't a lot out there that is guaranteed to work well with Saliba - who, given his record, may need cover anyway.
I wouldn't want to see ESR go but he doesn't look the same as he did. I think it would hinge on him getting more game time and seeing how he goes.
Party - Get a good offer and wave goodbye. He isn't irreplaceable and will miss to much game time through the ANC alone. Put a halfway decent midfield around Rice and we wouldn't even miss him.
posted on 2/11/23
Would give Kiwoir a run in the team tbh. He filled in well last season and has done pretty well every time he has played this season. Never really had a run with Saliba, and is the better passer Arteta wants that side of the defence.
Judging by early season Timber was here to replace Gabriel in the XI, although Zinnys absence may have forced that a bit.
Page 1 of 1