Boy, you don’t half talk excrement.

Someone desperate for attention again

So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?

comment by (K̇ash) - Liverpool 7-0 Man U - Free Palestine 🇵🇸 (U1108)
posted 30 minutes ago
Someone desperate for attention again
----------------------------------------------------------------------
From you ! First on an article on our board, looking for attention.

comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 47 minutes ago
So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the other 49 Muslim Countries aren't good enough for the Palestinians. Only the tiny one that isn't will do.

That person is very stupid then. Israelis don't even care if they kill their own, look up the Hannibal Directive.

Also, has the OP looked into how many weapons the UK itself sells to Saudi Arabia?

Stop watching YouTube videos.

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)
posted 4 minutes ago
That person is very stupid then. Israelis don't even care if they kill their own, look up the Hannibal Directive.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not Really, Ukraine laid down its nukes and look what happened.

Russia–Syria–Iran–Iraq coalition. No Israel in there in case you haven't noticed. Hardly paragons of virtue when it comes to their own citizens are they.

So why are Israelis murdering innocent Palestinians?

comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 47 minutes ago
So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the other 49 Muslim Countries aren't good enough for the Palestinians. Only the tiny one that isn't will do.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So, you want to ethnically cleanse them from that region?

comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 47 minutes ago
So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the other 49 Muslim Countries aren't good enough for the Palestinians. Only the tiny one that isn't will do.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So, you want to ethnically cleanse them from that region?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?

comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 47 minutes ago
So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the other 49 Muslim Countries aren't good enough for the Palestinians. Only the tiny one that isn't will do.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So, you want to ethnically cleanse them from that region?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I doubt they'd be welcomed, refugees are shot on site or worse (depending on whether you view a quick death as better than slow) when fleeing persecution and trying to make safe haven in the likes of Saudi Arabia...

comment by Two Balls, One Saka (U19684)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I doubt they'd be welcomed, refugees are shot on site or worse (depending on whether you view a quick death as better than slow) when fleeing persecution and trying to make safe haven in the likes of Saudi Arabia...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How can you be a refugee from a Country that doesn't exist? (according to Saudi Arabia)

comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 19 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
posted 47 minutes ago
So why is there no peace in the West Bank then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because the other 49 Muslim Countries aren't good enough for the Palestinians. Only the tiny one that isn't will do.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So, you want to ethnically cleanse them from that region?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The land of Palestine which they have been living in for thousands of years.

comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 18 minutes ago
comment by Two Balls, One Saka (U19684)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I doubt they'd be welcomed, refugees are shot on site or worse (depending on whether you view a quick death as better than slow) when fleeing persecution and trying to make safe haven in the likes of Saudi Arabia...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How can you be a refugee from a Country that doesn't exist? (according to Saudi Arabia)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Where would they be a refugee from?

comment by N2 (U22280)
---------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The land of Palestine which they have been living in for thousands of years.
---------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't think any of them have been alive for Thousands of years. Isn't this the same sort of historic reasoning about land ownership Putin used to justify an invasion of Ukraine?

comment by Two Balls, One Saka (U19684)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Where would they be a refugee from?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They wouldn't be a refugee, they'd be a migrant from their own Country if they stopped trying to claim another one as their own.

But as Saudia Arabia says that would let Israel off the hook. In actuality nobody in the Middle east wants Palestinians because they don't want Israel to exist. The welcome in the rest of the Middle East was sarcasm to highlight how small a bit of land they want.

It goes away from the point anyway as I say 49 muslim Countries, 1 tiny Jewish one.

If they left the tiny Jewish one alone and acted in Unison to do constructive things all would be good wouldn't it. But no, they can't do that because 49 countries isn't enough. As I say same reasoning Putin uses.

How many Palestinians have been killed compared with Israelis?

If you look at the wars in Yemen, Syria, Iraq, Iran etc. I do wonder how many people would have died if Israeli's upped and left the region long ago.

Quite a few more I expect. It's strange that people think the Middle East is comparable to Europe in terms of it's stabiity.

comment by Ali - (U1192)
posted 3 hours, 15 minutes ago
How many Palestinians have been killed compared with Israelis?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So you think Israel should have done a head count and retaliated by killing the same amount of Palestinians?

The numbers involved aren’t the issue. Hamas knew exactly how Israel would react when they carried out their own slaughter. It’s Hamas that effectively sealed the fate of the people they’re supposed to be protecting.

If the Arabs lay down their arms their will be peace.

If Israel lay down their arms,there will be no more Israel.

I believe that is as true now as when it was said
====
All a bit of a pointless thing to say.

The first statement is definitely false as there have been periods of peace. The last relative peace was broken when Israel was formed. The problem isn't the formation of Israel though, it's that a Palestinian state wasn't formed alongside the new Israel state.

So if Arabs lay down their arms will Israel allow them self determination? Laying down arms, while a honourable move, solves none of the Palestinians problems.

They'd still remain under apartheid, being displaced in favour of Israeli settlements, regular Israeli settler attacks, which are basically Jim Crow style lynchings of Palestinians, unlawfully and indefinitely detained without trial, Israel controlling and weaponising water, electricity and every facet of life, complete control over Palestinian life, no self determination and a second class citizen in that country.

So the bottom line if Israel stopped apartheid and allowed Palestinians to self determine, there'd be peace. Furthermore, if Israel hadn't been racist from the start, and treated everyone equally, the Palestinians wouldn't be so bitter today. After their formation, they didn't necessarily have to impose apartheid on Palestinians, and we wouldn't have this problem today.

Hamas was formed in 1987. Why was there no peace before that?

To translate OP.

Arabs need to know their place, might is right.

comment by Whyarewelosing (U23097)
posted 4 hours, 54 minutes ago
comment by N2 (U22280)
---------------------------------------
Which region are you referring to? The other 7 million sq km of the Middle East in which they'd be welcomed, the 22 thousand sq km of Israel, the 365 sq km they've used as a base to slaughter Israeli Children? Or something else?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The land of Palestine which they have been living in for thousands of years.
---------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't think any of them have been alive for Thousands of years. Isn't this the same sort of historic reasoning about land ownership Putin used to justify an invasion of Ukraine?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No, I was obviously countering the Israeli ownership claim.

comment by Terminator1 (U1863)
posted 59 minutes ago
comment by Ali - (U1192)
posted 3 hours, 15 minutes ago
How many Palestinians have been killed compared with Israelis?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So you think Israel should have done a head count and retaliated by killing the same amount of Palestinians?

The numbers involved aren’t the issue. Hamas knew exactly how Israel would react when they carried out their own slaughter. It’s Hamas that effectively sealed the fate of the people they’re supposed to be protecting.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Have you ever heard of international law? It exists for a reason, and Israel are signatories, along with all nations on this planet.

What you've described here is called collective punishment, one of the most serious crimes in international law. Collective punishment is a punishment or sanction imposed on a group for acts allegedly perpetrated by a member of that group, which could be an ethnic or political group, or just the family, friends and neighbors of the perpetrator. The term refers not only to criminal punishment, but also to other types of sanctions, harassment or administrative action taken against a group in retaliation for an act committed by an individual/s who are considered to form part of the group.

Many other leaders and countries over the decades have been done for similar contravention of international law. Israel has the most UN resolutions against it, more than any other country including states considered rogue or terrorist states like North Korea, Nepal, China etc but has never been sanctioned or punished like others because US, UK and allies protect them with bureaucracy and veto all the resolutions, allowing them to continue their apartheid.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Israel

Israel are commiting international crimes and killing thousands upon thousands of innocents, and it seems they have your approval.

Laws exist for a reason. Are you the British government? Are you NATO? Are terrorists correct to bomb the living daylights out of you and your loved ones because of actions committed by your government in facking up the middle east region?

So if I kill you and say I've done nothing wrong because the British government or NATO sealed your fate, you'd be OK with that?

That's basically what you're saying here.

Israel is like magic, otherwise logical people just can't think straight when it comes to Israel and make the most ridiculous arguments which they wouldn't make in other scenarios, probably because of a lifetime of biased news and social environments and their mama taking them to Sunday school growing up.