or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 98 comments are related to an article called:

Is Southgate underrated?

Page 4 of 4

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 6 hours, 30 minutes ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle (U4388)
posted 13 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle (U4388)
posted 41 seconds ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 44 minutes ago
He's not on Guardiola or Klopp's level of course, but I think he could do a good job for a team in 4th-6th which is exactly where united are right now.
======
Have to agree with this part.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
But why would Utd want a manager suited to 4-6th place when all they want is improvement? seems a tad nonsensical if he was appointed don't you think?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You are asking Mamba if he thinks?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah! got itLiverpool fan having a wee wum, fair play
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Not very well at that. The dips have probably been in those lower places just as often as us in the last decade or so.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Please see above.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wow Satty. You're losing it a bit more every day saan. That' doesn't mean lower places is defined as you say and it precedes this discussion anyway. Lower places means lower places. You're now trying to change that so you can win
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lol I expected a better attempt than this bro.

Look, enjoy your success, enjoy our failures. Let us have our surprised enjoyment that lower league finishes between are actually very close despite it not feeling that way.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
No.

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 30 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 29 seconds ago
You have had more success, no-one disputes that. When we’ve been ok you’ve had a bad season, when you’ve had a good season you’ve been immense, unlucky to come across this City behemoth. But the lower league positions in context which it derived, it’s actually very close between us even though, as I’ve said multiple times, it doesn’t feel that close until you look at it.
====
That's like saying something like it was close between Liverpool and United under Fergie because we had almost as many top 4 finishes as United.

It's quite a stretch and utterly absurd. Definitely those tinted spectacles
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No-one said “it was close” again here you are trying to shift the goal posts.

The point was lower league positions. That comes out 5-6 in favour of Liverpool. If you don’t think that is close, then I can point you to a kindergarten teacher to help you learn to count mate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't say anyone said anything. I said what I said. How can your argument be based on you telling me that nobody said something which I didn't claim somebody said?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You’ve lost this one badly Mamba. Enjoy Liverpool’s upcoming success. But here, you’re just wrong in any way that you try. You’re not precise enough to take me on.

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 19 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 43 seconds ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 6 hours, 30 minutes ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle (U4388)
posted 13 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle (U4388)
posted 41 seconds ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 44 minutes ago
He's not on Guardiola or Klopp's level of course, but I think he could do a good job for a team in 4th-6th which is exactly where united are right now.
======
Have to agree with this part.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
But why would Utd want a manager suited to 4-6th place when all they want is improvement? seems a tad nonsensical if he was appointed don't you think?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You are asking Mamba if he thinks?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ah! got itLiverpool fan having a wee wum, fair play
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Not very well at that. The dips have probably been in those lower places just as often as us in the last decade or so.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Please see above.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wow Satty. You're losing it a bit more every day saan. That' doesn't mean lower places is defined as you say and it precedes this discussion anyway. Lower places means lower places. You're now trying to change that so you can win
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lol I expected a better attempt than this bro.

Look, enjoy your success, enjoy our failures. Let us have our surprised enjoyment that lower league finishes between are actually very close despite it not feeling that way.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
No.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahahah fair enough

posted on 21/3/24

Viddy said "Despite them winning one title I think that have had much lower finishes than us as well."

And now you confirm "The point was lower league positions. That comes out 5-6 in favour of Liverpool."

So thanks for confirming Viddy was talking out his ass as usual. Facking knew it couldn't be accurate. I was right to challenge it and thanks for helping me out and completely destroying your reason for even engaging me in the first place.

I thought I told you I never lose.

I never lose saan

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 1 minute ago
Viddy said "Despite them winning one title I think that have had much lower finishes than us as well."

And now you confirm "The point was lower league positions. That comes out 5-6 in favour of Liverpool."

So thanks for confirming Viddy was talking out his ass as usual. Facking knew it couldn't be accurate. I was right to challenge it and thanks for helping me out and completely destroying your reason for even engaging me in the first place.

I thought I told you I never lose.

I never lose saan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Take that to VC. No charge for my helping you demonstrate that it’s not equal.

But I said:

It's much closer than it feels, that's for sure.

Then you said:

It's definitely nowhere near close


You lost to me saan

posted on 21/3/24

Bless you. You actually thought you won there šŸ¤£

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 1 minute ago
Viddy said "Despite them winning one title I think that have had much lower finishes than us as well."

And now you confirm "The point was lower league positions. That comes out 5-6 in favour of Liverpool."

So thanks for confirming Viddy was talking out his ass as usual. Facking knew it couldn't be accurate. I was right to challenge it and thanks for helping me out and completely destroying your reason for even engaging me in the first place.

I thought I told you I never lose.

I never lose saan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Take that to VC. No charge for my helping you demonstrate that it’s not equal.

But I said:

It's much closer than it feels, that's for sure.

Then you said:

It's definitely nowhere near close


You lost to me saan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Is this the best you've got? You think you've replied to what I said? Nothing there is even worthy of response or at the level of what I posted. You're basically just typing because you have to say something. Thanks for helping out Viddy in the bin.

Definitely a win for me

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 59 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 1 minute ago
Viddy said "Despite them winning one title I think that have had much lower finishes than us as well."

And now you confirm "The point was lower league positions. That comes out 5-6 in favour of Liverpool."

So thanks for confirming Viddy was talking out his ass as usual. Facking knew it couldn't be accurate. I was right to challenge it and thanks for helping me out and completely destroying your reason for even engaging me in the first place.

I thought I told you I never lose.

I never lose saan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Take that to VC. No charge for my helping you demonstrate that it’s not equal.

But I said:

It's much closer than it feels, that's for sure.

Then you said:

It's definitely nowhere near close


You lost to me saan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Is this the best you've got? You think you've replied to what I said? Nothing there is even worthy of response or at the level of what I posted. You're basically just typing because you have to say something. Thanks for helping out Viddy in the bin.

Definitely a win for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’


You cheap floozy Mamba.

Sat Nav - figuratively running rings around Mamba.

On your left Falcon

posted on 21/3/24

Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’
====
The parameters referred to in the first statement aren't the same as those in the second one you simpleton.

Furthermore, using your own info against you doesn't mean I take ownership of it. My job is to run rings around you and prove you don't know what you're talking about.

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 3 minutes ago
Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’
====
The parameters referred to in the first statement aren't the same as those in the second one you simpleton.

Furthermore, using your own info against you doesn't mean I take ownership of it. My job is to run rings around you and prove you don't know what you're talking about.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In that case, you’re fired due to gross incompetence.

“Definitely nowhere near close” lol

posted on 21/3/24

5-5 who finished above whom
5-6 on the 4th to 6th and lower parameters
3.7 average finish vs 4.4 (I’m not double checking my maths, feel free to)

Definitely nowhere near close lol

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Jaygarcia Saturn (U23145)
posted 1 hour, 54 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 8 hours, 17 minutes ago
To be fair, Southgate would have United play better football than Jose did.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You also
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Dont you have some goats to fondle?

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 3 minutes ago
5-5 who finished above whom
5-6 on the 4th to 6th and lower parameters
3.7 average finish vs 4.4 (I’m not double checking my maths, feel free to)

Definitely nowhere near close lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Your math's is fine. Mamba is a bit of a dunce for sure.

I can't even remember the last time we finished as low as eighth.

The dips were probably more consistent in the league before Klopp.

posted on 21/3/24

comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 40 minutes ago
Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’
====
The parameters referred to in the first statement aren't the same as those in the second one you simpleton.

Furthermore, using your own info against you doesn't mean I take ownership of it. My job is to run rings around you and prove you don't know what you're talking about.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Filter this old miserable fool and you will have a better experience here. I hardly see this stupid swine VC offering anything worthwhile to any thread.

Not hard to take this stupid plonker to the cleaners as you have shown.

posted on 21/3/24

comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 16 minutes ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 40 minutes ago
Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’
====
The parameters referred to in the first statement aren't the same as those in the second one you simpleton.

Furthermore, using your own info against you doesn't mean I take ownership of it. My job is to run rings around you and prove you don't know what you're talking about.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Filter this old miserable fool and you will have a better experience here. I hardly see this stupid swine VC offering anything worthwhile to any thread.

Not hard to take this stupid plonker to the cleaners as you have shown.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I live in your head rent free.

posted on 22/3/24

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 7 hours, 13 minutes ago
comment by Mamba the Chief Disinformation Officer on JA606 (U1282)
posted 3 minutes ago
Mamba: ‘those aren’t the parameters for lower positions’

Later Mamba: ‘wait those parameters help me prove VC wrong, yes I’ll use them’
====
The parameters referred to in the first statement aren't the same as those in the second one you simpleton.

Furthermore, using your own info against you doesn't mean I take ownership of it. My job is to run rings around you and prove you don't know what you're talking about.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In that case, you’re fired due to gross incompetence.

“Definitely nowhere near close” lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think you know what gross incompetence means. Furthermore, your replies are don't really make sense or follow the debate or explain anything. Might you be drunk by any chance?

posted on 22/3/24

have any of you lot figured out of southgate is just a bad choice or a terrible choice yet?

please do let us know.

posted on 22/3/24

comment by moreinjuredthanowen (U9641)
posted 19 minutes ago
have any of you lot figured out of southgate is just a bad choice or a terrible choice yet?

please do let us know.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Why? Is there something wrong with you apart from sentence construction issues?

posted on 22/3/24

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 15 hours, 44 minutes ago
comment by Jaygarcia Saturn (U23145)
posted 1 hour, 54 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 8 hours, 17 minutes ago
To be fair, Southgate would have United play better football than Jose did.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You also
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Dont you have some goats to fondle?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Proving my point here, no?

posted on 22/3/24

underrated

With the squad England have (and compared to the other heavyweight nations) and the lucky draws England have been gifted in recent tournaments, they've underachieved
Only France in recent years have comparable squad depth (and they've won a WC & lost another WC final on a pen shoot out)
The last Euros were a home tournament for England with a v favourable route through and they still didn't win !

Matches against:
Croatia 2018 WC semi
Italy 2020 Euro final
France 2022 WC quarters

would you say Southgate made the difference for England ?

they should have won at least 2 of those matches and with a better coach would have

posted on 23/3/24

England players under Southgate seem to get along better than the pool of talent of the golden generation. But many forget even during that time, there were many outstanding national sides.

Southgate has done a "fantastic job" for England as the high hopes England had in the late 90s to mid/late 00s disappeared. English fans basically accepted we're not the best or have the best players.

Now, England have a good set of players compared to many of the other national teams. Look at how the Netherlands, Italy, Germany and many other so called great national teams aren't as they once were. It still seems under Southgate, England fluff their lines. Itly and Croatia come to mind. In England's biggest matches, Southgate has always fluffed his lines.

And then there is the biggest issue. Managing a national team isn't anything like managing a modern club. Nd Southgate's pragmatism might get you far in international football but not warm you up to fans of a big club like United, where other than a few games, you're meant to attack.

Southgate would be a disaster for United and his own reputation. Both should steer clear of each other.

comment by Spurtle (U1608)

posted on 23/3/24

comment by Peks - now at the half century (U6618)
posted 20 hours ago
underrated

With the squad England have (and compared to the other heavyweight nations) and the lucky draws England have been gifted in recent tournaments, they've underachieved
Only France in recent years have comparable squad depth (and they've won a WC & lost another WC final on a pen shoot out)
The last Euros were a home tournament for England with a v favourable route through and they still didn't win !

Matches against:
Croatia 2018 WC semi
Italy 2020 Euro final
France 2022 WC quarters

would you say Southgate made the difference for England ?

they should have won at least 2 of those matches and with a better coach would have
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Got to agree with this. He has underachieved with England considering luck has been thrown his way time and time again.

Came in at a good time when many of the big international teams on the scene weren't what they were, as well as joining up with England when young talent was emerging, including inheriting a decent international keeper capable of saving a penalty for a change. Pickford saved more pens in his first penalty shootout than Robinson, James and Hart (who was also made to look an absolute caant) in theirs, as in actually saving one at all, and if we'd had any of them in 2018 England and Southgate may have gone out early the usual way against Colombia.

Nice qualifiable groups and easier draws compared to previous managers.

No major injuries to key players. I mean remember when we used to go into tournaments with Beckham injured or Rooney injured and rushed back to fitness? Even Owen injuring himself mid-tournament. It would be like Kane constantly injured prior to tournaments today but he's always been primed and ready to go along with our other good players.

No sense of injustice compared to previous tournaments either, like disallowed goals or goals being deemed not crossing the line that would otherwise keep us in games or win them for us.

He had a home tournament. There is a reason the only tournament we've ever won is at home.

And yet despite all of this we've still not won anything and still appear to keep getting bettered by the first decent team we face. Germany is the one exception, although they were and have been since a faded team, going through possibly the worst period in their history. We did face them at home mind you.

Southgate lost us the games against Croatia and Italy. Subs made too late. He even had a direct hand in our penalty failure against Italy by bringing on 2 pen takers so late in the game their first touches were practically the penalties.

So yes he's clueless and unlikely to do anything in the next tournament. Perfect for United though.

posted on 24/3/24

No

Page 4 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment