https://x.com/Andybho27665205/status/1869341546589642892

Rangers should really be complaining about the lack of penalties ever since Willie Collum replaced Crawford Allan.

Why have the penalties dried up?

Jefte red card challenge.

Diomande red card challenge.

Balogun red card challenge.

Tav poss 2nd yellow.

Hagi fouling all match, no card until the end.

Raskin fouling whole game, but booked on 91st min.

Pull on CCV for their 2nd goal.

Booking for CCV when he won the ball.

Kyogo booked when pulled down by propper (who should have been booked).

bUt wE sHudDa hUd A pEnALtY

comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 27 minutes ago
https://x.com/Andybho27665205/status/1869341546589642892
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Belter

Not wild about the GB but i admire the work they do with tifos and the foodbank collections.

They are pretty childish about chants at celtic park, if they dont lead it they dont get involved, find that a bit pathetic.

https://x.com/Zeshankenzo/status/1869290142562984279?t=UY-tnFRxG73AuqYPN6Krag&s=19

Strange

comment by Frank Connor - VAR Expert (U21900)
posted 2 days, 11 hours ago
comment by The Mighty Quinn (U4099)
posted 3 minutes ago

<As for the “penalty”; it’s been explained over and over that it seems Beaton was too keen to blow his whistle as soon as he saw the initial foul. You don’t carry on after that point and it’s really that simple.>

Blue on Blue.

Amazing how so many can't grasp a simple reality.

Soon as the offence is called the ball is out of play.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Wait.. what..? Do you mean as soon as the Referee blows his whistle, the ball is no longer in play, and play cannot continue? Remarkable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Just reminding myself of the remarkable referee experts we have on this forum, seeing there’s a lot of new takes being posted

comment by Frank Connor - VAR Expert (U21900)
posted 2 hours, 48 minutes ago
https://x.com/Zeshankenzo/status/1869290142562984279?t=UY-tnFRxG73AuqYPN6Krag&s=19

Strange
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The ball was definitely moving for the first one. Had to be retaken.

comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 2 hours, 55 minutes ago
comment by Frank Connor - VAR Expert (U21900)
posted 2 days, 11 hours ago
comment by The Mighty Quinn (U4099)
posted 3 minutes ago

<As for the “penalty”; it’s been explained over and over that it seems Beaton was too keen to blow his whistle as soon as he saw the initial foul. You don’t carry on after that point and it’s really that simple.>

Blue on Blue.

Amazing how so many can't grasp a simple reality.

Soon as the offence is called the ball is out of play.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Wait.. what..? Do you mean as soon as the Referee blows his whistle, the ball is no longer in play, and play cannot continue? Remarkable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Just reminding myself of the remarkable referee experts we have on this forum, seeing there’s a lot of new takes being posted
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many 'new takes' have been posted. Don't think I've seen any that i haven't seen elsewhere

Also..are you saying that you need to be referee expert to express an opinion?

That Lint boy has put in some shift over the last few days.

comment by Magnum (3 in a row easy) (U22391)
posted 36 minutes ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 2 hours, 55 minutes ago
comment by Frank Connor - VAR Expert (U21900)
posted 2 days, 11 hours ago
comment by The Mighty Quinn (U4099)
posted 3 minutes ago

<As for the “penalty”; it’s been explained over and over that it seems Beaton was too keen to blow his whistle as soon as he saw the initial foul. You don’t carry on after that point and it’s really that simple.>

Blue on Blue.

Amazing how so many can't grasp a simple reality.

Soon as the offence is called the ball is out of play.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Wait.. what..? Do you mean as soon as the Referee blows his whistle, the ball is no longer in play, and play cannot continue? Remarkable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Just reminding myself of the remarkable referee experts we have on this forum, seeing there’s a lot of new takes being posted
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many 'new takes' have been posted. Don't think I've seen any that i haven't seen elsewhere

Also..are you saying that you need to be referee expert to express an opinion?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Since the penalty was proved to be a factual error, there’s been a lot of new none incidents raised by Celtic fans.

And no idea why you would allude to me having said that.

comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Magnum (3 in a row easy) (U22391)
posted 36 minutes ago
comment by RenegadeOF (U9457)
posted 2 hours, 55 minutes ago
comment by Frank Connor - VAR Expert (U21900)
posted 2 days, 11 hours ago
comment by The Mighty Quinn (U4099)
posted 3 minutes ago

<As for the “penalty”; it’s been explained over and over that it seems Beaton was too keen to blow his whistle as soon as he saw the initial foul. You don’t carry on after that point and it’s really that simple.>

Blue on Blue.

Amazing how so many can't grasp a simple reality.

Soon as the offence is called the ball is out of play.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Wait.. what..? Do you mean as soon as the Referee blows his whistle, the ball is no longer in play, and play cannot continue? Remarkable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Just reminding myself of the remarkable referee experts we have on this forum, seeing there’s a lot of new takes being posted
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many 'new takes' have been posted. Don't think I've seen any that i haven't seen elsewhere

Also..are you saying that you need to be referee expert to express an opinion?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Since the penalty was proved to be a factual error, there’s been a lot of new none incidents raised by Celtic fans.

And no idea why you would allude to me having said that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was probably your use of the term 'remarkable referee experts'. I wasn't sure where you were going with it. I didn't see anyone claim to be an expert.

There were certainly a number of incidents in the game where the officials favoured Rangers. I'm not sure how you interpret them as being 'new'. They either happened in the 90 minutes or they didn't.
The only one that's a 'none incident' is the mcgregor free kick. The ball was rolling when he took it. The ref was right to order a re-take.

can we replay the scottish cup final where hartson had a goal chopped off despite being 2 yards offside.

also, get caley on the phone and get that semi final replayed where they handballed it on the line, with an official 5 yards away.

in fact, i DEMAND! we replay all games that had decisions which didn't go in our favour because they didn't correctly adhere to the catholic conspiracy.

And the recent Scottish Cup semi against Rangers where Celtic should’ve had two penalties.

Was that the Bobby Madden semi when he failed to give Bassey and the Helium Hardman three yellow cards apiece…? Bobby the St Mirren fan, but his grandad took him to all the Rangers home games…

Very happy with Collum's comments on the VAR review show

Was clearly a penalty, and it is a major error from the VAR

I'm glad it went to VAR, and I'm glad we heard the audio

The bit that got me most was where he says "it's more outside"........that just showa a complete an dutter level of incompetence for me.....if it's at all inside it's a pen, that's the rule, he should know that

I was saying the Beaton should have been called over to the monitor to at least look at it, but I'm even more happy that Collum has said that shouldn't even have happened, as this was as an easy decision to make, it was factual, and an immediate overrule of Beaton should have happened because the VAR has clear evidence of a foul in the box

Only thing left to stay is...I don't want to even begin imagining the uproar of the shoe had been on the other foot here and it had happened to Celtic and it was they who had lost the cup final

This is an extremely poor error by the referees, it has been slated by the man on charge of the referees....and that's now two league cup finals against you that we have had major decision go against us (Julien offside before VAR came in, and the pen in ET on Sunday)

Pi$h pi$h poor from the VAR

the shoe has been on the other foot stevie.

the refs went on strike because we had the audacity to call them out when they were lying.

the official came out and said the ref lied, the official who was honest got binned and the refs went on strike.

we've had more than our fair share of "bad" decisions over the years and proven corruption during rangers 9 in a row run.

literally withholding player registrations to help rangers.

thats cheating.

this was a bad call.

Does this mean we have to hand 119 back?

comment by JFK - Super Nintendo Chalmers (U8919)
posted 8 minutes ago
the shoe has been on the other foot stevie.

the refs went on strike because we had the audacity to call them out when they were lying.

the official came out and said the ref lied, the official who was honest got binned and the refs went on strike.

we've had more than our fair share of "bad" decisions over the years and proven corruption during rangers 9 in a row run.

literally withholding player registrations to help rangers.

thats cheating.

this was a bad call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jim Farry!!! The whole second half of that season should be replayed.

comment by JFK - Super Nintendo Chalmers (U8919)
posted 6 minutes ago
the shoe has been on the other foot stevie.

the refs went on strike because we had the audacity to call them out when they were lying.

the official came out and said the ref lied, the official who was honest got binned and the refs went on strike.

we've had more than our fair share of "bad" decisions over the years and proven corruption during rangers 9 in a row run.

literally withholding player registrations to help rangers.

thats cheating.

this was a bad call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly my point

Dunno if you have noticed but a lot of things have happened to us as a club over the last couple decades

Last thing I'm gonna do is start dragging up old $hit from decades ago....on a count of bad decisions going against us...and I'll be ashamed of any bear who does

This hasn't even happened to you here, and you are already bringing up the McDonald incident (after the correct call was made on the pitch), aswell as Jim Farry and all sorts.....

We've had bad decisions go against us, we are not happy about it and we don't want it to happen again

Don't think we will see any ref strikes being forced as a result of it....but if this had happened to Celtic, there's every bloody chance

comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 15 minutes ago
Very happy with Collum's comments on the VAR review show

Was clearly a penalty, and it is a major error from the VAR

I'm glad it went to VAR, and I'm glad we heard the audio

The bit that got me most was where he says "it's more outside"........that just showa a complete an dutter level of incompetence for me.....if it's at all inside it's a pen, that's the rule, he should know that

I was saying the Beaton should have been called over to the monitor to at least look at it, but I'm even more happy that Collum has said that shouldn't even have happened, as this was as an easy decision to make, it was factual, and an immediate overrule of Beaton should have happened because the VAR has clear evidence of a foul in the box

Only thing left to stay is...I don't want to even begin imagining the uproar of the shoe had been on the other foot here and it had happened to Celtic and it was they who had lost the cup final

This is an extremely poor error by the referees, it has been slated by the man on charge of the referees....and that's now two league cup finals against you that we have had major decision go against us (Julien offside before VAR came in, and the pen in ET on Sunday)

Pi$h pi$h poor from the VAR
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What exactly do you think would have happened if the shoe had been on the other foot and Celtic had lost the final?

comment by JFK - Super Nintendo Chalmers (U8919)
posted 5 minutes ago
the shoe has been on the other foot stevie.

the refs went on strike because we had the audacity to call them out when they were lying.

the official came out and said the ref lied, the official who was honest got binned and the refs went on strike.

we've had more than our fair share of "bad" decisions over the years and proven corruption during rangers 9 in a row run.

literally withholding player registrations to help rangers.

thats cheating.

this was a bad call.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Beat me to it

The shoe has been on the other foot many may times

I am glad that people now want full transparency from refereeing, we have been calling for it for decades.

That official who was asked to lie ended up working in a factory as his refereeing career was over.

I suspect the Rangers fans also want full clarity on a number of decisions, just a couple without repeating what every Celtic fan has been saying-
Cadete goal chopped off which effectively gifted Rangers that league's title
Handball by Inverness in clear view of the officials
Yang red card for a high boot yet similar incidents were deemed ok
Penalty awarded for the ball hitting Bernabei from behind at close range
Penalty awarded for the ball brushing AJ's arm by his side
A penalty awarded for Rangers against Celtic because the ref thought he heard some contact

Just wondering-there’s another incident that VAR got wrong in that clip from the Dundee Utd game. Any claims from the teams about cheating or anything? Has that VAR team been stood down?

comment by Magnum (3 in a row easy) (U22391)
posted 14 minutes ago
comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 15 minutes ago
Very happy with Collum's comments on the VAR review show

Was clearly a penalty, and it is a major error from the VAR

I'm glad it went to VAR, and I'm glad we heard the audio

The bit that got me most was where he says "it's more outside"........that just showa a complete an dutter level of incompetence for me.....if it's at all inside it's a pen, that's the rule, he should know that

I was saying the Beaton should have been called over to the monitor to at least look at it, but I'm even more happy that Collum has said that shouldn't even have happened, as this was as an easy decision to make, it was factual, and an immediate overrule of Beaton should have happened because the VAR has clear evidence of a foul in the box

Only thing left to stay is...I don't want to even begin imagining the uproar of the shoe had been on the other foot here and it had happened to Celtic and it was they who had lost the cup final

This is an extremely poor error by the referees, it has been slated by the man on charge of the referees....and that's now two league cup finals against you that we have had major decision go against us (Julien offside before VAR came in, and the pen in ET on Sunday)

Pi$h pi$h poor from the VAR
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What exactly do you think would have happened if the shoe had been on the other foot and Celtic had lost the final?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Same as what rangers are doing. Nothing.

you have to take it on the chin ultimately.

Can't change the decision once its given.

comment by Timmy (U14278)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Magnum (3 in a row easy) (U22391)
posted 14 minutes ago
comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 15 minutes ago
Very happy with Collum's comments on the VAR review show

Was clearly a penalty, and it is a major error from the VAR

I'm glad it went to VAR, and I'm glad we heard the audio

The bit that got me most was where he says "it's more outside"........that just showa a complete an dutter level of incompetence for me.....if it's at all inside it's a pen, that's the rule, he should know that

I was saying the Beaton should have been called over to the monitor to at least look at it, but I'm even more happy that Collum has said that shouldn't even have happened, as this was as an easy decision to make, it was factual, and an immediate overrule of Beaton should have happened because the VAR has clear evidence of a foul in the box

Only thing left to stay is...I don't want to even begin imagining the uproar of the shoe had been on the other foot here and it had happened to Celtic and it was they who had lost the cup final

This is an extremely poor error by the referees, it has been slated by the man on charge of the referees....and that's now two league cup finals against you that we have had major decision go against us (Julien offside before VAR came in, and the pen in ET on Sunday)

Pi$h pi$h poor from the VAR
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What exactly do you think would have happened if the shoe had been on the other foot and Celtic had lost the final?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Same as what rangers are doing. Nothing.

you have to take it on the chin
----------------------------------------------------------------------
s

Dunno if you have noticed but a lot of things have happened to us as a club over the last couple decades.

=========

yeah you were brutally allowed to start again in the fourth tier after dodging taxes and not having to pay back millions of pounds used to win trophies.

hard done by because you had to start again in the fourth tier and not get preferential treatment to just wander right into the top league?

Rangers got everything they deserved, and this perceived suffering of their fans is what most clubs outwith the old firm just call "being a fan".

However, they have been grossly mismanaged at a club to a point where their fans seem to think that they just need more anger to succeed. Everything stupid and bad about rangers could have been left at the door in the fourth tier, but it seems to have made some of them worse