comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 27 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think you are proving my point here re pre-1992 football.
Prior to 70's there were few foreigners playing in UK, anyone outscoring Aguero would be familiar to us oldies.
Just remember one - George Robledo, a Chilean played for Newcastle in the early 50's, scored plenty of goals per game but don't think he stayed in England long enough.
Just checked Wikipedia, Aguero 85 in England, Robledo 82 for Newcastle and also 45 for Barnsley (not top division).
So again it depends on how to want to interpret this, highest goals scored in England -Robledo. Prem league (or top division) - Aguero
Just remembered one
=========
Yeah, remembered
comment by puffinthebushkangaroo2 (U20236)
posted 3 minutes ago
Just remember one - George Robledo, a Chilean played for Newcastle in the early 50's, scored plenty of goals per game but don't think he stayed in England long enough.
Just checked Wikipedia, Aguero 85 in England, Robledo 82 for Newcastle and also 45 for Barnsley (not top division).
So again it depends on how to want to interpret this, highest goals scored in England -Robledo. Prem league (or top division) - Aguero
-------
I suspected something like this might be the case. So Aguero's is an all time record. Still they prefer to go with calling it a premier league record. That's just ridiculous if true.
comment by puffinthebushkangaroo2 (U20236)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 27 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think you are proving my point here re pre-1992 football.
Prior to 70's there were few foreigners playing in UK, anyone outscoring Aguero would be familiar to us oldies.
------
It really clearly doesn't.
comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the first decent question I've seen in this debate over two threads. And I can't reasonably answer it in a positive way other than the prem want to 'own' that record. True, it's a silly record and would have meant nothing to anyone previously - but that's the case for a lot of 'records'. A fair few are nonsense and only, repeat only, exist to be included in promotional material and make it all seem more 'exciting'.
This is the first decent question I've seen in this debate over two threads. And I can't reasonably answer it in a positive way other than the prem want to 'own' that record.
-----
I agree, and I think it's ridiculous.
^ You often hear these Premier League 'records' referred to during match commentaries. Many of them are fairly spurious like the 'highest scoring South American'.
I also remember a reference to 'the highest scoring World Cup winner.'
This duality of all-time, top flight records and Premier League 'records' will continue to be a divisive issue.
Give me an all-time, top flight record any day.
Premier League records exist, fair enough, but they often only tell half - or less - of the [his]story.
Whatever floats your boat - or bounces your basketball -
I guess.
Sign in if you want to comment
Vardy - 1 more to EQUAL the record
Page 8 of 8
6 | 7 | 8
posted on 2/12/15
comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 27 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think you are proving my point here re pre-1992 football.
Prior to 70's there were few foreigners playing in UK, anyone outscoring Aguero would be familiar to us oldies.
posted on 2/12/15
Just remember one - George Robledo, a Chilean played for Newcastle in the early 50's, scored plenty of goals per game but don't think he stayed in England long enough.
Just checked Wikipedia, Aguero 85 in England, Robledo 82 for Newcastle and also 45 for Barnsley (not top division).
So again it depends on how to want to interpret this, highest goals scored in England -Robledo. Prem league (or top division) - Aguero
posted on 2/12/15
Just remembered one
=========
Yeah, remembered
posted on 2/12/15
comment by puffinthebushkangaroo2 (U20236)
posted 3 minutes ago
Just remember one - George Robledo, a Chilean played for Newcastle in the early 50's, scored plenty of goals per game but don't think he stayed in England long enough.
Just checked Wikipedia, Aguero 85 in England, Robledo 82 for Newcastle and also 45 for Barnsley (not top division).
So again it depends on how to want to interpret this, highest goals scored in England -Robledo. Prem league (or top division) - Aguero
-------
I suspected something like this might be the case. So Aguero's is an all time record. Still they prefer to go with calling it a premier league record. That's just ridiculous if true.
posted on 2/12/15
comment by puffinthebushkangaroo2 (U20236)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 27 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think you are proving my point here re pre-1992 football.
Prior to 70's there were few foreigners playing in UK, anyone outscoring Aguero would be familiar to us oldies.
------
It really clearly doesn't.
posted on 2/12/15
comment by Mamba - Sterling, what's the score? (U1282) (U13041)
posted 1 hour, 55 minutes ago
Watching motd last week they said that Aguero is now the highest scoring south American in the premier league followed by Tevez and Suarez. I wanted to find out whether this is an all time record or prem only record but all the info I can find is from 1992 onwards. Anyone know or got a link? If it's an all time record, why refer to it as a prem record?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is the first decent question I've seen in this debate over two threads. And I can't reasonably answer it in a positive way other than the prem want to 'own' that record. True, it's a silly record and would have meant nothing to anyone previously - but that's the case for a lot of 'records'. A fair few are nonsense and only, repeat only, exist to be included in promotional material and make it all seem more 'exciting'.
posted on 2/12/15
This is the first decent question I've seen in this debate over two threads. And I can't reasonably answer it in a positive way other than the prem want to 'own' that record.
-----
I agree, and I think it's ridiculous.
posted on 2/12/15
^ You often hear these Premier League 'records' referred to during match commentaries. Many of them are fairly spurious like the 'highest scoring South American'.
I also remember a reference to 'the highest scoring World Cup winner.'
This duality of all-time, top flight records and Premier League 'records' will continue to be a divisive issue.
Give me an all-time, top flight record any day.
Premier League records exist, fair enough, but they often only tell half - or less - of the [his]story.
Whatever floats your boat - or bounces your basketball -
I guess.
Page 8 of 8
6 | 7 | 8