Carroll

The jury's out, as far as I'm concerned. Took his goal really well, but the tackle he got carded for concerned me a little, maybe a discipline issue there?

Zero makes a good point; if he's getting good service he'll thrive; if not, he'll look distinctly ordinary...

If you need to watch the highlights: http://www.footytube.com/video/liverpool-valencia-aug06-86685?ref=hp_ozeit_mp

I have seen all the games so far and he has improved especially fitness wise which is a massive factor for any striker!
This proves that at least he is taking the training seriously, and Kenny will be passing on invaluable experience which it appears is showing early signs of fruition!

Have to admit, for all the abusehe's had from WUMs on here about being fat oand slow, he showed some turn of pace for his goal...

A few defenders and keepers are going to be scared s-hitless when they see Carroll coming at them with full speed.

I'd still like to see a back up for him though

I was worried about his turn of pace but if he is training well (and losing a bit of weight) then I reckon he could be a handful! Good to hear positive comments...

I have to apologise for all my typos this morning, I'm on a train and my thumbs are too fat for this stupid little phone...

Hes a white heskey

As a Liverpool + Posh supporter, I think Carroll has enormous potential and hope that he starts fulfilling that potential this season, starting on Saturday.

He'd be a good back up to David Ball and Lee Tomlin.....not sure he's capable of being any good above Championship level though.