I think it is insulting to Keane that he is compared with average players like Vieria. Keane should be consierderd with the greats like Zidane etc

Liverpool are our rivals, city are just noisy neighbours (U6419)
at least u aint Denying it,i like a truthfull person

at least u aint Denying it,i like a truthfull person


You must desise your manager then.

*despise.

Roy Keane v Juventus 1999. That ends this debate

---------------------------------------------

If the pinnacle of Keane's career according to Utd fans is a single Semi-Final Champions League match. Then I would say Vieira pinnacle as Club Captain for Arsenal is this...

P38 W26 D12 L0

I think the debate has just ended.

Anyone remember arsenal's thug attack on ruud?

Keane was slightly better than viera

Keane led his team to a treble and many leagues and cups. Viera led his team to 2/3? leagues and a few cups. Treble is more impressive than undefeated season

If the pinnacle of Keane's career according to Utd fans is a single Semi-Final Champions League match. Then I would say Vieira pinnacle as Club Captain for Arsenal is this...

P38 W26 D12 L0

I think the debate has just ended.

Aye, well done on managing to draw a few games that season against the likes of Leicester and Portsmouth. Keane did at the highest level, whereas Viera, and Arsenal in general, have constantly been found wanting where it really matters, in Europe.

The voice in wenger's head - Free Luka! Free Cesc! Free Wesley! Free Samir! Free Carlos! Free Alberto! Free Emmanuel! Let my people go! (U7100)

the reson Arsenal players attacked Horseface is because he CHEATED to get that pen,then when he missed Priceless.

GOAT, the fact that you do not realise or refuuse to accept the quality of Vieira proves you are nothing more than a WUM with nothing constructive to offer to this debate.

In my opinion there is very little to draw between the 2 players but if i had to go for one it would have to be Keane. Only because i think he had more EPL experience and thus was influential in not only the big games like Vieira.

Other than that being a personal opinion i dont think any two better DM have ever played in the EPL.

comment by Anti_Stan_KRONK_EE (U1179)
------------
You have Pires diving to thank for that record. Would prefer 4 losses and 3 cups to 0 league losses and 1 cup

the reson Arsenal players attacked Horseface is because he CHEATED to get that pen


So why didn't they publicly horsewhip Robert Pires for his cheating the week before against Portsmouth? By the way Van Nistlerooy didn't win the penalty, Forlan did. Your lack of footballing knowledge offends me.

the reson Arsenal players attacked Horseface is because he CHEATED to get that pen,then when he missed Priceless.
------------------------------------------------
In that case the undefeated season is meaningless and based on cheating as I remember a certain Pires dive. Arsenal players dive all the time but you don't see opposing teams attacking them. Just admit it that the players behaviour was disgraceful

The voice in wenger's head - Free Luka! Free Cesc! Free Wesley! Free Samir! Free Carlos! Free Alberto! Free Emmanuel! Let my people go! (U7100)

Thomas Gravesen was the Dirtyest player to ever grace the Premiership.

As you stated THUNDERASS, its your preference. You are entitled to it.

Me i prefer Sprite!!!

Liverpool are our rivals, city are just noisy neighbours (U6419)
Horseface won the pen,and like Viera said in his Autobiography Horseface is a CHEAT and a COWARD,he got that one right

My top PL centre mid players

1)Scholes
2)Keane
3)Gerrard
4)Gravesen
5)Vieira

Dirty GRAVESEN

Liverpool are our rivals, city are just noisy neighbours (U6419)
Horseface won the pen,and like Viera said in his Autobiography Horseface is a CHEAT and a COWARD,he got that one right
------------------------------------
actually forlan won the penalty at it was a foul. Vieira kicked ruud and got sent off. And Paddy v must consider his buddy henry a huge cheat

Gea earn over makelele?!? How does that work?

Gravesen not gea

Egg on my face

x4 - (U9335)

In terms of number of games played and trophies then Scholes wins hands down.

However in terms of leadership qualities and game winning performances then we need not mention Scoles in the same as PV and RK.

comment by 21 Gun Salute (U9103)

posted 4 minutes ago

As you stated THUNDERASS, its your preference. You are entitled to it.

Me i prefer Sprite!!!
----------------
Good choice but in 5 or 6 years time try beer, it's better than Sprite