If it was a straight choice between Rooney and Sturridge then Rooney all day long, don't even have to think about it.

However, I wouldn't want Rooney back anyway, time to look to the future, not backwards

Couldn't see Liverpool selling Sturridge to Everton

comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 second ago
Couldn't see Liverpool selling Sturridge to Everton
----------------------------------------------------------------------

To save it going into a contest of value etc, lets say both came on a free and both earned 50k a week.....which one would you prefer?

comment by Arouna Jagielka oooh I wanna take ya, Heitinga Nikica come on pretty mama (U1308)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 second ago
Couldn't see Liverpool selling Sturridge to Everton
----------------------------------------------------------------------

To save it going into a contest of value etc, lets say both came on a free and both earned 50k a week.....which one would you prefer?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Even as a United fan I'd still probably have to say Sturridge then. The only doubt would be his fitness

comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Arouna Jagielka oooh I wanna take ya, Heitinga Nikica come on pretty mama (U1308)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by The Process (U20671)
posted 1 second ago
Couldn't see Liverpool selling Sturridge to Everton
----------------------------------------------------------------------

To save it going into a contest of value etc, lets say both came on a free and both earned 50k a week.....which one would you prefer?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Even as a United fan I'd still probably have to say Sturridge then. The only doubt would be his fitness
----------------------------------------------------------------------

These are the sort of things you need to consider when money is taken out of the equation.

Team moral, impact to the club, what he offers on and ft of he pitch(for both players)

Everton should try and get both. I've always had a soft spot for the toffees, and now, with your current team and manager, you're definitely the dark horse in the top 6. Would love to see what Koeman & co could do if you qualified for CL.

Good-luck this weekend.

If fit Sturridge. I haven't seen anything from Rooney of late that makes me think he'd be a good acquisition.

fitness - rooney
mental attitude - rooney
being a winner - rooney
future value - sturridge
goals if they ever GET fit - sturridge
most likely to annoy the rest of the squad - sturridge
amount of abuse away fans will give them - draw

comment by gbwolf V - golden ring (U17280)
posted 45 minutes ago
fitness - rooney
mental attitude - rooney
being a winner - rooney
future value - sturridge
goals if they ever GET fit - sturridge
most likely to annoy the rest of the squad - sturridge
amount of abuse away fans will give them - draw
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I already stated that for discussion purposes the sell on value would be zero. They would be a free transfer and 50k wages.

Sturridge and Lukaku upfront all day long for me

A front three from

Lukaku
Rooney
Mirallas
Barkley
Lookman

I think it would be great for Rooney to join in (he would have to take a substantial wage cut of course) and it's also good for the PL that one of the most distinguished players is to stay put for few short years than to go to the far east - joining his childhood club would be a preferable choice.

But on the other hand - still surprised that Everton wants to bring him back, being slower and lost his touches - not certain he would start each week for an ambitious club like Everton, who are on a positive move?

comment by Great_Red_Shark (U1711)
posted 8 hours, 3 minutes ago
I think it would be great for Rooney to join in (he would have to take a substantial wage cut of course) and it's also good for the PL that one of the most distinguished players is to stay put for few short years than to go to the far east - joining his childhood club would be a preferable choice.

But on the other hand - still surprised that Everton wants to bring him back, being slower and lost his touches - not certain he would start each week for an ambitious club like Everton, who are on a positive move?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

My OP had a line....both came in a free and both would earn 50k with no resale value.