or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 327 comments are related to an article called:

The Craig Whyte Trial

Page 8 of 14

posted on 21/4/17

comment by My POV-got my name back for a couple of days! (U10636)
posted 26 minutes ago
Surprise witness has just been called up. Should get the full story now.

https://mobile.twitter.com/mcmanus1888/status/855435778775711745/photo/1
----------------------------------------------------------------------

comment by lauders (U9757)

posted on 21/4/17

Heed will tell you tomorrow

posted on 21/4/17

I haven't gone through the whole thread, but all you need is on the link below. As has probably been said already - you just feel like you're in an alternative universe when you read about Donald Findlay cross examining Walter and Ally in a court of law

https://twitter.com/jamesdoleman

posted on 21/4/17

comment by My POV-got my name back for a couple of days! (U10636)
posted 34 minutes ago
Surprise witness has just been called up. Should get the full story now.

https://mobile.twitter.com/mcmanus1888/status/855435778775711745/photo/1


Belter

comment by lauders (U9757)

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 15 minutes ago
I haven't gone through the whole thread, but all you need is on the link below. As has probably been said already - you just feel like you're in an alternative universe when you read about Donald Findlay cross examining Walter and Ally in a court of law

https://twitter.com/jamesdoleman
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doubt most his stuff is real

posted on 21/4/17

comment by lauders - JA 6s Champion. Choose Rangers, choose the battle hymns, choose getting powered for being dead and causing trouble in Manchester on a daily basis, choose having more shysters than bar L, choose a swalley in the louden before the game Choose life (U9757)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 15 minutes ago
I haven't gone through the whole thread, but all you need is on the link below. As has probably been said already - you just feel like you're in an alternative universe when you read about Donald Findlay cross examining Walter and Ally in a court of law

https://twitter.com/jamesdoleman
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Doubt most his stuff is real
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's Ginger you're thinking about.

posted on 21/4/17

Only read the last coupla posts & heading to subway.

Anybody gets this thread closed will be on the Naughty Step.







posted on 21/4/17

comment by The Mighty Quinn (U4099)
posted 2 minutes ago
Only read the last coupla posts & heading to subway.

Anybody gets this thread closed will be on the Naughty Step.








----------------------------------------------------------------------

Arsenal fans are utter thundercunts

posted on 21/4/17

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Timmy (U14278)

posted on 21/4/17

James Doleman‏ @jamesdoleman
Findlay asks Smith if a football club's wage structure includes "bonus" for success on the field
He replies yes, for players and management

So they admit they cheated

posted on 21/4/17

Timmy - let's not over egg the pudding here, mate - I had a bonus scheme during most of my 38 year management career, and I never cheated

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 5 minutes ago
Timmy - let's not over egg the pudding here, mate - I had a bonus scheme during most of my 38 year management career, and I never cheated
----------------------------------------------------------------------
STB becomes EBT.....

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Zeek (U21090)
posted 15 minutes ago
I wish we had a legal expert on this site.
Someone with expert knowledge of Law.
Like a lawyer and not a brickie that's read a book.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
FFS man. Give it up.

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Curly 💩 - I'm mumpsimus and I know it.' (except on a Wednesday, that is my obstreperous day ) - ITS JIST A BIG CLIQUE N'AT (U1103)
posted 2 hours, 25 minutes ago
I don't quite get why they are examining the guys on the fitba side and asking fitba related questions
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Curly....I sometimes kid on that I'm obsessed but I'm not really...so I'm not really 100% what this trial is actually about (happy if someone wants to enlighten me).

But I can't for the life of me understand the relevance of any of this testimony. I'm sure that Findlay in particular knows what he is doing but I'm astonished that the judge is allowing any of this. It looks like circumstantial twaddle to me.

posted on 21/4/17

POV

Didn't MEAN to sound so defensive.....

posted on 21/4/17

BTW...I'm in the US at the moment and an ad just popped up for a product that gives you relief from clenching and grinding. No idea what it was but I'll pass the number on it if comes up again. America...what a country

posted on 21/4/17

Mags - you in the USA? Well, who'd a thunk it?

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Stevethebhoy (U17159)
posted 3 seconds ago
Mags - you in the USA? Well, who'd a thunk it?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fack off you....away and get merried or sumthing

posted on 21/4/17

posted on 21/4/17

comment by Magnum (U16400)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by Curly 💩 - I'm mumpsimus and I know it.' (except on a Wednesday, that is my obstreperous day) - ITS JIST A BIG CLIQUE N'AT (U1103)
posted 2 hours, 25 minutes ago
I don't quite get why they are examining the guys on the fitba side and asking fitba related questions
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Curly....I sometimes kid on that I'm obsessed but I'm not really...so I'm not really 100% what this trial is actually about (happy if someone wants to enlighten me).

But I can't for the life of me understand the relevance of any of this testimony. I'm sure that Findlay in particular knows what he is doing but I'm astonished that the judge is allowing any of this. It looks like circumstantial twaddle to me.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It does seem a really odd line of questioning to go down. Sure I read they reckon it could last up to 12 weeks-how the fluck are they going to spin it out for that long?!?

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 21/4/17

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 21/4/17

Silver...what is that actually a defence against (I'm not up to date with this trial).

Are these even defence witnesses?

posted on 21/4/17

Silver-it's more about him lying and acting fraudulently about the funds available rather than how they died....

posted on 21/4/17

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 21/4/17

I'm thinking (for what it's worth and that's not a lot these days 🙁) that Finlay is setting out the scenario that the club was already in dire straits with the bank about to call it in, the two tax cases and high unsustainable costs which meant that it was irrelevant as to what Whyte did as it wounding have changed anything.

Also the likes of Smith and McCoist were responsible in some way toward the continuation of taking on debt and one had fiduciary duties which he will say he failed in.

Added to that there is already the acknowledgment that the club knew what but we as doing in continuing to pursue players it couldn't afford and that dependence upon Europe was a massive gamble. A gamble too far.

Hence, what else could Whyte do but try and rescue the club by whatever means possible and it isn't uncommon to depend upon financing against upcoming season tickets. Ergo, Whyte acted in the onky way he could and that the club and its officers already had the club on the road to ruin before he came on board.

My thoughts anyway but I don't profess to be a legal beagle.

Page 8 of 14

Sign in if you want to comment