Nay!

No one

I don't see the point, but I think he may even walk. He doesn't look happy, he's hinted the players aren't playing for him and he doesn't strike me as the type to hold on for money.

I just don't see a good alternative. Of all the young, foreign managers out there, he was the one all of our fans and a lot of big clubs were looking at.

We could go PL proven, but then we're starting all over again, giving our players the easy way out all over again.

Nay!

All united fans want him sacked.
All fans of every other club want him to remain manager.

That should tell you enough.

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 40 seconds ago
I don't see the point, but I think he may even walk. He doesn't look happy, he's hinted the players aren't playing for him and he doesn't strike me as the type to hold on for money.

I just don't see a good alternative. Of all the young, foreign managers out there, he was the one all of our fans and a lot of big clubs were looking at.

We could go PL proven, but then we're starting all over again, giving our players the easy way out all over again.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I take it youre on the Nay! Side at this time?

comment by Ali - 🇪🇦 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 (U1192)
posted 1 minute ago
All united fans want him sacked.
All fans of every other club want him to remain manager.

That should tell you enough.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So you're Aye!

Seems to me that he's suffering from depression, and awaiting a nice pay-off !

comment by #01 🟥⬜⬛ House ~ The Cycle is complete o... (U17162)
posted 6 seconds ago
comment by Ali - 🇪🇦 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 (U1192)
posted 1 minute ago
All united fans want him sacked.
All fans of every other club want him to remain manager.

That should tell you enough.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So you're Aye!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Of course. I'm not trying to upset anyone or cause offence, but any genuine united fan that wants him to stick around is an absolute mental case.

How is anyone happy watching us play with 5 defenders against Grimsby? FFS

comment by H von H. (U16981)
posted 2 minutes ago
Seems to me that he's suffering from depression, and awaiting a nice pay-off !
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He's already said he'd walk without a pay off if the club wanted.

He looks like he's checking out. Ideally he decides he's had enough and walks.

His system is a huge issue. It's not the way top teams play. You've undoubtedly improved the squad, giving them a better foundation would get better results but he's not going to change his idea.

comment by #01 🟥⬜⬛ House ~ The Cycle is complete once more, we are back to sack the manager (U17162)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 40 seconds ago
I don't see the point, but I think he may even walk. He doesn't look happy, he's hinted the players aren't playing for him and he doesn't strike me as the type to hold on for money.

I just don't see a good alternative. Of all the young, foreign managers out there, he was the one all of our fans and a lot of big clubs were looking at.

We could go PL proven, but then we're starting all over again, giving our players the easy way out all over again.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I take it youre on the Nay! Side at this time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For the time being, yes. I'd give him the next 3/4 PL games and expect the players to put in performances like against Arsenal.

If we don't then yes, we need a change. I just don't see who will be available so early into the season.

Any ideas?

I want him to succeed, of course... But i'm struggling.. The formation, the football, the man management (or lack of) of the players he doesn't want, even the hiding away from the penalties... It's all making to very hard to see the positives.

comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin (U2958)
posted 2 seconds ago
I want him to succeed, of course... But i'm struggling.. The formation, the football, the man management (or lack of) of the players he doesn't want, even the hiding away from the penalties... It's all making to very hard to see the positives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's funny how a week changes things.

We were all full of positivity following a decent window, the payer/ manager interviews and a good showing against Arsenal.

Though I agree, we've gone backwards since ETH left, which is depressing to say.

Losing a promising young player, for whatever reason, is always frustrating and disappointing. Given that United aren't overwhelmed with talent at the moment pushing Mainoo out - and that's what it looks like - is fecking insane.

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin (U2958)
posted 2 seconds ago
I want him to succeed, of course... But i'm struggling.. The formation, the football, the man management (or lack of) of the players he doesn't want, even the hiding away from the penalties... It's all making to very hard to see the positives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's funny how a week changes things.

We were all full of positivity following a decent window, the payer/ manager interviews and a good showing against Arsenal.

Though I agree, we've gone backwards since ETH left, which is depressing to say.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't pay any attention to pre-season.. So was blissfully unaware of the idea of Bruno in CM.

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by #01 🟥⬜⬛ House ~ The Cycle is complete once more, we are back to sack the manager (U17162)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 40 seconds ago
I don't see the point, but I think he may even walk. He doesn't look happy, he's hinted the players aren't playing for him and he doesn't strike me as the type to hold on for money.

I just don't see a good alternative. Of all the young, foreign managers out there, he was the one all of our fans and a lot of big clubs were looking at.

We could go PL proven, but then we're starting all over again, giving our players the easy way out all over again.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I take it youre on the Nay! Side at this time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For the time being, yes. I'd give him the next 3/4 PL games and expect the players to put in performances like against Arsenal.

If we don't then yes, we need a change. I just don't see who will be available so early into the season.

Any ideas?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's in my name.

It's pretty boring saying the same serious responses over and over again. Each of us here just says the same thing about why they want their manager in or gone season after season.

In this thread you don't need to put any effort into explaining your reasoning, just a simple aye or nay will do

comment by Busby (U19985)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin (U2958)
posted 2 seconds ago
I want him to succeed, of course... But i'm struggling.. The formation, the football, the man management (or lack of) of the players he doesn't want, even the hiding away from the penalties... It's all making to very hard to see the positives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's funny how a week changes things.

We were all full of positivity following a decent window, the payer/ manager interviews and a good showing against Arsenal.

Though I agree, we've gone backwards since ETH left, which is depressing to say.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The arsenal game was an anomaly

No manager should be sacked after 3 games, especially not one who’s just been allowed to spend £200m+ in the summer. Let’s see what he can do over the coming months before we all start wetting ourselves

Ask again at 5pm tomorrow

I reckon we might have a few suicides on this site by then if we don’t win.

NO one should want a Man United manager to get sacked. That usually means we're doing badly.

Let's see how we go tomorrow. If we did play well over the 90 and win then that would be 5 halves out of 6 we've done OK in in the PL this season.

I know that's clutching at straws but the metrics do suggest we're better than the results are showing. We just need average keeping and average forward play to get better results.

Nay

Sick of sacking managers. It's time we went through all the pain and come out the other side.

Alternative, more players new manager doesn't want, more players who need to be sold but can't be, more dejection in the squad, more distuption, more new players needed to suit the next guy, more mish mash of a squad. More failure, more sacking the next manager, repeat.

I honestly don't mind if we have to get worse before we get better no matter how long it takes, that's football.

comment by Playmaker (U22780)
posted 48 seconds ago
Nay

Sick of sacking managers. It's time we went through all the pain and come out the other side.

Alternative, more players new manager doesn't want, more players who need to be sold but can't be, more dejection in the squad, more distuption, more new players needed to suit the next guy, more mish mash of a squad. More failure, more sacking the next manager, repeat.

I honestly don't mind if we have to get worse before we get better no matter how long it takes, that's football.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This. I keep trying to say this but it's futile.

Might as well stick to just saying nay!

comment by #01 🟥⬜⬛ House ~ The Cycle is complete once more, we are back to sack the manager (U17162)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Playmaker (U22780)
posted 48 seconds ago
Nay

Sick of sacking managers. It's time we went through all the pain and come out the other side.

Alternative, more players new manager doesn't want, more players who need to be sold but can't be, more dejection in the squad, more distuption, more new players needed to suit the next guy, more mish mash of a squad. More failure, more sacking the next manager, repeat.

I honestly don't mind if we have to get worse before we get better no matter how long it takes, that's football.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This. I keep trying to say this but it's futile.

Might as well stick to just saying nay!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Equally futile if the one you stick with is the wrong man.