comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 32 minutes ago
He says ‘I wasn’t expecting you so soon’, right...

It’s been nearly 30 years he last saw Ashoka...
ok, Vader saw Ashoka just a few years ago, and tried to kill her, so... which one is he?!

Revenge of the Sith Ani, or Post Return of the Jedi Ani?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh and I think that maybe the not expecting to see you so soon implies that she’s died and this is where force users go after they die and maybe that’s why he’s not glowing there but would glow as a force ghost.

Who knows….

If most of the episode is 'anakin' and ahsoka shooting the shat then what a complete waste of time.

comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 35 seconds ago
If they quickly play it off in say five mins as some kind of trick then fine. If we spend thirty mins reminiscing and crap about where it all went wrong then I am out.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have a feeling it will be the majority of the episode reminiscing.

And no way is Ahsoka dead so what's the point

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 10 seconds ago
comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 35 seconds ago
If they quickly play it off in say five mins as some kind of trick then fine. If we spend thirty mins reminiscing and crap about where it all went wrong then I am out.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have a feeling it will be the majority of the episode reminiscing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Sadly i suspect you will be right. What a feckin waste. Just to give a nod to the anoraks. Oh look, character everyone knows, lets get excited....feckin yawn.

comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 48 seconds ago
And no way is Ahsoka dead so what's the point
----------------------------------------------------------------------
She’s been dead before I think. I didn’t mean permanently dead

Isn't episode five supposed to be an event??

Surely they wouldn't bore us with shat like that right?

comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 10 seconds ago
comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 35 seconds ago
If they quickly play it off in say five mins as some kind of trick then fine. If we spend thirty mins reminiscing and crap about where it all went wrong then I am out.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have a feeling it will be the majority of the episode reminiscing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Sadly i suspect you will be right. What a feckin waste. Just to give a nod to the anoraks. Oh look, character everyone knows, lets get excited....feckin yawn.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeh, I’d be disappointed if most of it is a trip down memory lane only to pull the rug from under us in the last moments...
to me, it doesn’t make sense it being Anakin... unless it’s that straight forward and it is.
So he’s been in the WBW all this time, and he chose this moment to save her, have a trip down memory lane, and then get her back to go after Thrawn.

What if episode 5 is them going through moments during the prequels and original trilogy?

comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 4 minutes ago
What if episode 5 is them going through moments during the prequels and original trilogy?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I’m sure the majority of it will be. OT not so much.

Think it will all be ‘what if’ Ahsoka tried to help Anakin etc ‘I left you master’ etc

can't wait zzzzzzzzzz

so where is ahsoka when the original trilogy came out? Dead?

But what’s the reasoning for the Memory Lane chat?
She’s on a mission to get to Thrawn, she ain’t got time for this… unless the future has already been told….

I dunno…

So the prevailing theories are…
1. Anakin has been in the WBW, after his death in RotJ. and chose now to reconnect with her to have a chat.

2, It’s not Anakin, it’s Palpatine playing games.

3. It’s not Anakin, it’s the Gods from CW playing games.

4. Ahsoka is unconscious, maybe in the ocean somewhere, and a Purgill has picked her up, and she is just dreaming.

That aboot cover it…

comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 1 minute ago
so where is ahsoka when the original trilogy came out? Dead?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Good question…. Maybe this is where we find out

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 14 seconds ago
comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 1 minute ago
so where is ahsoka when the original trilogy came out? Dead?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Good question…. Maybe this is where we find out
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly.

Episode 5 may also include flashbacks of Ahsoka's journey post order 66.

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 2 minutes ago
But what’s the reasoning for the Memory Lane chat?
She’s on a mission to get to Thrawn, she ain’t got time for this… unless the future has already been told….

I dunno…

So the prevailing theories are…
1. Anakin has been in the WBW, after his death in RotJ. and chose now to reconnect with her to have a chat.

2, It’s not Anakin, it’s Palpatine playing games.

3. It’s not Anakin, it’s the Gods from CW playing games.

4. Ahsoka is unconscious, maybe in the ocean somewhere, and a Purgill has picked her up, and she is just dreaming.

That aboot cover it…
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think it's a force dream.

The reasoning for the dream is to help her character overcome the guilt that she still has over Anakin's turn. The attachment.

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Cinciwolf----Old Trafford record attendance.....WOLVES V GRIMSBY. .......lolz (U11551)
posted 1 minute ago
so where is ahsoka when the original trilogy came out? Dead?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Good question…. Maybe this is where we find out
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How can she be dead during the OT but alive in this series?

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 50 seconds ago
But what’s the reasoning for the Memory Lane chat?
She’s on a mission to get to Thrawn, she ain’t got time for this… unless the future has already been told….

I dunno…

So the prevailing theories are…
1. Anakin has been in the WBW, after his death in RotJ. and chose now to reconnect with her to have a chat.

2, It’s not Anakin, it’s Palpatine playing games.

3. It’s not Anakin, it’s the Gods from CW playing games.

4. Ahsoka is unconscious, maybe in the ocean somewhere, and a Purgill has picked her up, and she is just dreaming.

That aboot cover it…
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I am with No4 tbh, shes unconscious and the recent Anakin discussion has her dreaming this.......but she will use the WBW to find Thrawn etc

And as far as I am aware Ashoka just left Anakin at the end of the CW, and then the last we saw was she was rescued by Ezra in Rebels after "dying"

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 11 minutes ago
But what’s the reasoning for the Memory Lane chat?
She’s on a mission to get to Thrawn, she ain’t got time for this… unless the future has already been told….

I dunno…

So the prevailing theories are…
1. Anakin has been in the WBW, after his death in RotJ. and chose now to reconnect with her to have a chat.

2, It’s not Anakin, it’s Palpatine playing games.

3. It’s not Anakin, it’s the Gods from CW playing games.

4. Ahsoka is unconscious, maybe in the ocean somewhere, and a Purgill has picked her up, and she is just dreaming.

That aboot cover it…
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah good summary

comment by Simon West (U1830)
posted 40 minutes ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 50 seconds ago
But what’s the reasoning for the Memory Lane chat?
She’s on a mission to get to Thrawn, she ain’t got time for this… unless the future has already been told….

I dunno…

So the prevailing theories are…
1. Anakin has been in the WBW, after his death in RotJ. and chose now to reconnect with her to have a chat.

2, It’s not Anakin, it’s Palpatine playing games.

3. It’s not Anakin, it’s the Gods from CW playing games.

4. Ahsoka is unconscious, maybe in the ocean somewhere, and a Purgill has picked her up, and she is just dreaming.

That aboot cover it…
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I am with No4 tbh, shes unconscious and the recent Anakin discussion has her dreaming this.......but she will use the WBW to find Thrawn etc

And as far as I am aware Ashoka just left Anakin at the end of the CW, and then the last we saw was she was rescued by Ezra in Rebels after "dying"
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I wouldn't say she left Anakin. The galaxy had been plunged into darkness and the jedi were being hunted down and killed, so she went into hiding.

Dave Filoni is directing episode 5 so expect a significant amount of references and lore.

So Guv, you thinking something like, she’s dreaming Anakin, so we go down memory lane.. then she wakes, and see’s the map burned into her hand and she finds a way to get to Thrawn.

Purgill prehaps..or hitches a ride with Hera, and we back on track.

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 9 minutes ago
So Guv, you thinking something like, she’s dreaming Anakin, so we go down memory lane.. then she wakes, and see’s the map burned into her hand and she finds a way to get to Thrawn.

Purgill prehaps..or hitches a ride with Hera, and we back on track.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes.

The map certainly has been imprinted onto her had or brain.

As for how they get there, it's either Hera's ship or they use something in Ahsoka's ship.

Hera is gonna scoop her up. Hopefully sooner rather than later so we can get the story moving along.

comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 hour, 1 minute ago
So Guv, you thinking something like, she’s dreaming Anakin, so we go down memory lane.. then she wakes, and see’s the map burned into her hand and she finds a way to get to Thrawn.

Purgill prehaps..or hitches a ride with Hera, and we back on track.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

The sequels (well 2 and 3) gave me strong Harry Potter vibes with the linked minds crap. Wouldn’t surprise me if this is another HP style bit where the hero ‘dies’ get a pep talk from their mentor and comes back stronger.

I agree with Guv - force dream. Anakin will free her from any guilt and tell her how amazing she is - from the trailer “you can do this Ahsoka, I know you can”. She’ll awake and go ass-kicking with a new focus. That would be my guess anyway.