or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 124 comments are related to an article called:

Hernandez!!!

Page 2 of 5

posted on 26/9/13

Yeah Darren. I'm on about this season. What is this Moyes guy up to?

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 26/9/13

This is such a stupid argument.

"Hernandez is better than Welbeck so should start instead of him".

Well yeah but he's not competing with Welbeck is he? He's competing with Van Persie so rightly doesn't start most games. Most of Welbeck's games he plays on the left where he is infinitely better than Hernandez.

posted on 26/9/13

But RVP's injured. Why not push Rooney up front and play Kagawa behind him?
Or play Hernandez as a CF and Rooney behind him? Very odd.

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 26/9/13

But RVP's injured. Why not push Rooney up front and play Kagawa behind him?
Or play Hernandez as a CF and Rooney behind him? Very odd.

------------------------------------------

I take it you didn't catch United vs. Liverpool last night?

posted on 26/9/13

What does versatile even mean?
Is that means just taking up random positions ob the pitch without contributing anything?
Because I am struggling to name any contribution he has done playing out wideapart from running which even Hernandez can do all day long.
So the versatile argument needs to be put to bed.
Hernandez is far more versatile as h scores more variety of goals and also has a few fancy trixks uphis sleeve.
Left foot, right foot, head, face, tap in you name anything Hernandez has scored.

Welbeck isnt versatility
oshea was versatile, Rooney is versatile" Jones is versatile but Welbeck?

posted on 26/9/13

Rooney hasn't play as a number 9 in years, he plays behind the striker because he loves dropping back into midfield

posted on 26/9/13

I'm not too sure, to be honest.

When Welbeck start up top he makes us a little more flexible tactically as he will peal out wide a lot more than Hernandez.

That's probably one of the main reasons as Hernandez is just a much better striker.

posted on 26/9/13

"I take it you didn't catch United vs. Liverpool last night?"

Yeah. One game. I don't see why you're so defensive here. Relax.
Welbeck isn't good enough to start for a top club like Man U.

posted on 26/9/13

RVP

Ok Welbeck's more versatile you say,but at what?
Does it do that versatile thing( perhaps wing play)
better than Nani, kagawa, young etc?
If not why play him instead of them?

Don't we agree that kagawa should rather be used
on that left wing than Danny Welbeck?

I suspect its not just a football capability thing.

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 26/9/13

Yeah. One game. I don't see why you're so defensive here. Relax.
Welbeck isn't good enough to start for a top club like Man U.

------------------------------------------

I'm not being defensive. And i mostly agree with you. I'm just saying that your suggestion was utilised last night and it's not as if we've had much opportunity to implement it other than last night.

posted on 26/9/13

dubbed has more knowledge than some fans here that says something.

posted on 26/9/13

Ok Welbeck's more versatile you say,but at what?

He can play on the wing, as demonstrated last season.

Don't we agree that kagawa should rather be used
on that left wing than Danny Welbeck?

Yes I think that's what we should be doing

posted on 26/9/13

wayne being a again.

thank feck youve been banned from making articles

posted on 26/9/13

comment by RVP's Left Foot - Katy Perry (U11781) posted 17 minutes ago
Chicharito is class, I hope he gets more game time

--------------------------------
That would mean dropping RVP which I can't see happening

posted on 26/9/13

Welbeck isn't good enough to start for a top
club like Man U.
---------------
Him and Young aren't good to be at the club let alone start games.

posted on 26/9/13

Do you guys actually understand how the team you support plays?

Chicarito is kept out of the team because of Van Persie, not Welbeck.

posted on 26/9/13

"dubbed has more knowledge than some fans here that says something."

No shame in that. I have more knowledge than most people tbf.

posted on 26/9/13

dunc I get it you were bummed by Welbeck.

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 26/9/13

Do you guys actually understand how the team you support plays?

Chicarito is kept out of the team because of Van Persie, not Welbeck.

--------------------------------------------

The idiocy displayed by W&R knows no bounds.

posted on 26/9/13

Young is a garbage player. I've always maintained that. Even when he was at Villa.
Complete headless chicken.

posted on 26/9/13

very witty wayne,

my comment about you being a is obviously factual, whereas your comment isnt

posted on 26/9/13

That would mean dropping RVP which I can't
see happening

Chicarito is kept out of the team because of
Van Persie, not Welbeck.

------------------
clueless again.
remind me who started up top at City?

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 26/9/13

And who started up top last night W&R?

posted on 26/9/13

I dont get the "welbeck has a good all around game" either to be honest. sorry manc fans

its like a myth that has gotten bigger and bigger.

working hard for the team imo is not what i would call having an all around game otherwise scott parker has a good all around game too.

rooney imo has an all around game not welbeck

posted on 26/9/13

clueless again.
remind me who started up top at City?

........................

Rare wouldn't you say in the last two seasons. Wellbeck starting as a # 9?

Please try and put some thought into your reply, just this one time.

Page 2 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment