or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 125 comments are related to an article called:

All Time PL 11 with a Twist

Page 2 of 5

posted on 19/2/14

Schmeichel was shît at Villa, Irwin past it at Wolves, likewise Vieira at City.
Interesting also that you haven't included Schmeichel in your first XI...

posted on 19/2/14

--------------------------P. Schmeichel (Aston Villa)----------------------

Irwin(Wolves)--Ferdinand(West Ham)--Campbell(Spurs)--Baines(Wigan)

Pires(Arsenal)----Vieira(City)----Gerrard(Liverpool)----Giggs (United)

-----------------Drogba(Chelsea)----------Rooney(Everton)---------------

soooo stupid. I'm sorry. This is the best possinle team. Thank you and good night

posted on 19/2/14

Plus you have two Arsenal players...

Try again.

posted on 19/2/14

We all dream of a team of Carraghers

comment by Obers (U3904)

posted on 19/2/14

These teams are a little bit cheap. The rules should be you are not allowed to field two players who have played for the same club at ANY stage in their career. Anyway since I don't have time to do the 2nd one I will do my all time Premier League XI:

-------------------------------Cech---------------------

Neville---------Carvalho------Terry-----------Cole

---------------------Vieira-------Scholes-------------

Ronaldo-------------------Zola-------------------Bale

----------------------------Shearer-----------------------


-Goalkeeper with the most clean sheets in the Premier League era.
-3 of the 4 defenders have the best defensive record of the Premier League era.
-Midfield 2 I don't doubt anyone would have these two in their top 5 pl midfielders.
-3 behind the striker and 3 of the most talented players to grace the Premier League.
-PL's highest goalscorer upfront.

How could anyone disagree?

posted on 19/2/14

-----------Schmeichel--------------

neville----Admas---Vidic---Cole

Ronaldo---Keane--Viera--Giggs

---------Shearer ---Henry--------------



--------------------Given--------------

------king-----Kompany----Mcgrath-----

Pires------Scholes---Speed----Ginola

---------------------Le Tiss-----------------

-------------Drogba----Fowler-------



posted on 19/2/14

Schmichael
Irwin King Adams Cole
Viera Keane
ronaldo Giggs
Gerrard
Suarez

Just my team lots won't agree but that's a side I'd love to watch play.

posted on 19/2/14

---------------Seaman--------------------

--G Neville----Vidić----Adams-----Cole---

-Ronaldo----Keane-------Scholes-----Bale-

--------------Shearer-----Henry---------------


--------------------------P. Schmeichel (Aston Villa)----------------------

Irwin(Wolves)--Ferdinand(West Ham)--Campbell(Spurs)--Baines(Wigan)

Pires(Arsenal)----Vieira(City)----Gerrard(Liverpool)----Giggs (United)

-----------------Drogba(Chelsea)----------Rooney(Everton)---------------

This is my final answer. I forgot that none of my best IX should be in the one from every club IX

posted on 19/2/14

comment by kneerash-23 Cara Gold (U6876)
posted 55 seconds ago
Schmichael
Irwin King Adams Cole
Viera Keane
ronaldo Giggs
Gerrard
Suarez

Just my team lots won't agree but that's a side I'd love to watch play.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

not much width to that formation

posted on 19/2/14

what i wanna know is how the feck is emile heskey 6th in the all time pl appearance charts

posted on 19/2/14

Forgot all about Man City Could have had YaYa or Aguero in the team

posted on 19/2/14

Schmichael
Cole
Adams
King
Neville
Keane
Gerrard
Viera
Ronaldo
Henry
Suarez

posted on 19/2/14

comment by Mike C. (U19272)
posted 2 minutes ago
Schmichael
Cole
Adams
King
Neville
Keane
Gerrard
Viera
Ronaldo
Henry
Suarez
----------------------------------------------------------------------


i understand Suarez is a good player, but seriously

posted on 19/2/14

---------------Seaman--------------------

--G Neville----Vidić----Adams-----Cole---

-Ronaldo----Keane-------Scholes-----Bale-

--------------Shearer-----Henry---------------


--------------------------P. Schmeichel (Aston Villa)----------------------

Irwin(Wolves)--Ferdinand(West Ham)--Campbell(Spurs)--Baines(Wigan)

-Pires(Arsenal)----Vieira(City)----Gerrard(Liverpool)----Giggs (United)-

-----------------Drogba(Chelsea)----------Rooney(Everton)---------------

CAN ANYONE BEAT ME... AS YOU CAN SE MY BEST IX IS AS GOOD AS ONE FROM EACH CLUB BEST IN, WHICH I THINK IS THE ULTIMATE GOAL OF THIS GAME, AND I DIDN'T BREAK ANY RULES.

Anypne??? Ok no. Thank you and good night

posted on 19/2/14

It was him or Shearer and quite frankly I'd rather have the south american

posted on 19/2/14

Thanks for the contributions guys, it is interesting to see that across most teams some players are constant

posted on 19/2/14

But what about a prem best 11 of players who never won anything?

That would be interesting

posted on 19/2/14

comment by FrimBöue (U12551)
posted 1 hour, 46 minutes ago
___________________________Schmeicel__________________
Lauren (pompy)_Campbell (spurs)_Toure (lfc)_cole(Cfc)

Ljungberg(westham)_Veira (City) Parlour ( Boro )____pires (villa)

_____________Kev Campbell ( Everton )____Henry (Arsenal)___________

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Fixed it for you.

posted on 19/2/14

comment by ★Hombre Los Lando. (U7798)
posted 3 minutes ago
But what about a prem best 11 of players who never won anything?

That would be interesting
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'll start - Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G,
Super Steven no Tropheeeee

posted on 19/2/14

comment by Shinjisshin (U1700)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by ★Hombre Los Lando. (U7798)
posted 3 minutes ago
But what about a prem best 11 of players who never won anything?

That would be interesting
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'll start - Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G,
Super Steven no Tropheeeee
----------------------------------------------------------------------
champions league

posted on 19/2/14

comment by Shinjisshin (U1700)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by ★Hombre Los Lando. (U7798)
posted 3 minutes ago
But what about a prem best 11 of players who never won anything?

That would be interesting
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I'll start - Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G, Stevie, Stevie G,
Super Steven no Tropheeeee
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Surely he has won the CL, a few FA and League cups?

posted on 19/2/14

--------------martyn---------------

??----------??---??-------Pearce

??------------??----??-----Bale

------Ferdinand----Philips----


thats all ive got

comment by Chronic (U3423)

posted on 19/2/14

Gareth southgate over Ledley King?

posted on 19/2/14

How can we talk about long distinguished careers and not include the likes of Gary Speed and Brad Friedel ?

posted on 19/2/14

--------------martyn---------------

Jenkinson----------Metersacker--Koscielny-------Pearce

Walcott---------Ramsey------------Arteta--------Bale

------Ferdinand----Philips----

Page 2 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment