"How can La Liga allow them to spend the money they don’t have to complete these transfers"
is the cry from fans.
doesnt make sense to me , why is ok for one team to spend others money and not others?
You have no idea how liquidity works and also don't understand that different leagues have different rules. Discussion over
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 6 seconds ago
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This will be more entertaining than that great friendly series, the Ashes.
You have had myriad chartered accountants and financial experts tell you the difference, and yet you persist with the same, baseless arguments?
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
comment by Clockwork Red: Jadon and the Argonauts (U4892)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 6 seconds ago
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This will be more entertaining than that great friendly series, the Ashes.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Is this the same guy? Eww
still no takers on the question being asked?
Do Man Utd fans not see the irony in complaining about clubs in debt spending money on players.
"How can La Liga allow them to spend the money they don’t have to complete these transfers"
comment by rooney_hernandez (U7012)
posted 58 seconds ago
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thats over a year old that info
The whole salary thing rankles. Its the main reason why players choose to join them, even though they can't actually register them yet without getting rid of players they don't want. Players who they also coaxed to them with massive salary offers in the first place
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 28 seconds ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It hit a nerve? You wrote an article about it. The only person it's hit a nerve with is you, you absolute walloper 😂
comment by Raheemer (U5245)
posted 1 minute ago
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
does any of that matter? thats not the point im raising thats different feel free to create a thread on that if you want.
IM asking can you not see the irony of a club who have large levels of debt complaining about a team with large levels of debt buying players?
One club has silly debt but their revenues cover it. Players on silly contracts still.
Other club has silly debt but they are selling future revenue streams to buy additional.players. can't register players due to them being massively over the wage cap.
Players still on silly contracts. Club makes players differ silly contracts so new players coming in can have silly contracts. Still can't register players due to the wage cap. Decide best course of action is to sign more players on silly contracts.
How are they the same OP?
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the real irony is you using the word irony incorrectly. Kinda like an irony inception.
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
give examples?
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 20 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the real irony is you using the word irony incorrectly. Kinda like an irony inception.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert. New season, clean slate?👀ðŸ¤
comment by FootyMcfootfoot (U21853)
posted 27 seconds ago
One club has silly debt but their revenues cover it. Players on silly contracts still.
Other club has silly debt but they are selling future revenue streams to buy additional.players. can't register players due to them being massively over the wage cap.
Players still on silly contracts. Club makes players differ silly contracts so new players coming in can have silly contracts. Still can't register players due to the wage cap. Decide best course of action is to sign more players on silly contracts.
How are they the same OP?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
who said its the same im asking a question you al refuse to answer
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Raheemer (U5245)
posted 1 minute ago
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
does any of that matter? thats not the point im raising thats different feel free to create a thread on that if you want.
IM asking can you not see the irony of a club who have large levels of debt complaining about a team with large levels of debt buying players?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No. End thread.
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by rooney_hernandez (U7012)
posted 58 seconds ago
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thats over a year old that info
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you actually sure? The club's financial period end is 30 June; companies (particularly, PLCs) are required to have their accounts audited before publication so, y'know, they don't just print "we make 100 billion pounds a week..."
Those audits take MONTHS, and that's on the assumption of timely and accurate source information from the internal finance and accounting functions at United.
All in all, you won't see the FY22 accounts before September. So, if you're telling me that you're an auditor at PwC (you're not, you wouldn't have made it through the first exam) AND you're on the United audit AND MUFC's internal teams somehow pulled together all the requisite information FIFTEEN DAYS AFTER THE PERIOD END I will LITERALLY eat my nuts, film it, put it on YouTube, throw up the contents and paint "I'm sorry I doubted you, whodunnit" on the camera lens
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 45 seconds ago
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
give examples?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
https://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/446423
Man has mortgage and keeps his payments up and has no defaulted debts and goes and buys a huge TV and everyone is happy.
Man has mortgage and can’t keep up the repayments nor his credit card debts nor his council tax and still goes and buys large TV. Not everyone is happy.
Thus concludes Robb’s economics lesson.
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 17 seconds ago
Man has mortgage and keeps his payments up and has no defaulted debts and goes and buys a huge TV and everyone is happy.
Man has mortgage and can’t keep up the repayments nor his credit card debts nor his council tax and still goes and buys large TV. Not everyone is happy.
Thus concludes Robb’s economics lesson.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
But but but but they both have debt.
Sign in if you want to comment
Barcelona - just as bad
Page 1 of 3
posted on 15/7/22
"How can La Liga allow them to spend the money they don’t have to complete these transfers"
is the cry from fans.
doesnt make sense to me , why is ok for one team to spend others money and not others?
posted on 15/7/22
You have no idea how liquidity works and also don't understand that different leagues have different rules. Discussion over
posted on 15/7/22
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 6 seconds ago
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This will be more entertaining than that great friendly series, the Ashes.
posted on 15/7/22
You have had myriad chartered accountants and financial experts tell you the difference, and yet you persist with the same, baseless arguments?
posted on 15/7/22
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Clockwork Red: Jadon and the Argonauts (U4892)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 6 seconds ago
OP, I’m just gonna get a deck chair and some popcorn and sit down and enjoy you being schooled by people who understand money.
Brb.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This will be more entertaining than that great friendly series, the Ashes.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Is this the same guy? Eww
posted on 15/7/22
still no takers on the question being asked?
Do Man Utd fans not see the irony in complaining about clubs in debt spending money on players.
"How can La Liga allow them to spend the money they don’t have to complete these transfers"
posted on 15/7/22
comment by rooney_hernandez (U7012)
posted 58 seconds ago
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thats over a year old that info
posted on 15/7/22
The whole salary thing rankles. Its the main reason why players choose to join them, even though they can't actually register them yet without getting rid of players they don't want. Players who they also coaxed to them with massive salary offers in the first place
posted on 15/7/22
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
posted on 15/7/22
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
posted on 15/7/22
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
posted on 15/7/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 28 seconds ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It hit a nerve? You wrote an article about it. The only person it's hit a nerve with is you, you absolute walloper 😂
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Raheemer (U5245)
posted 1 minute ago
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
does any of that matter? thats not the point im raising thats different feel free to create a thread on that if you want.
IM asking can you not see the irony of a club who have large levels of debt complaining about a team with large levels of debt buying players?
posted on 15/7/22
One club has silly debt but their revenues cover it. Players on silly contracts still.
Other club has silly debt but they are selling future revenue streams to buy additional.players. can't register players due to them being massively over the wage cap.
Players still on silly contracts. Club makes players differ silly contracts so new players coming in can have silly contracts. Still can't register players due to the wage cap. Decide best course of action is to sign more players on silly contracts.
How are they the same OP?
posted on 15/7/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the real irony is you using the word irony incorrectly. Kinda like an irony inception.
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
give examples?
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 20 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
I have literally given no opinion all I did was ask if certain poster couldnt see the irony in complaining about a team in debt spending money on players. It seemed to hit a nerve? no idea why?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think the real irony is you using the word irony incorrectly. Kinda like an irony inception.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert. New season, clean slate?👀ðŸ¤
posted on 15/7/22
comment by FootyMcfootfoot (U21853)
posted 27 seconds ago
One club has silly debt but their revenues cover it. Players on silly contracts still.
Other club has silly debt but they are selling future revenue streams to buy additional.players. can't register players due to them being massively over the wage cap.
Players still on silly contracts. Club makes players differ silly contracts so new players coming in can have silly contracts. Still can't register players due to the wage cap. Decide best course of action is to sign more players on silly contracts.
How are they the same OP?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
who said its the same im asking a question you al refuse to answer
posted on 15/7/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Raheemer (U5245)
posted 1 minute ago
Do United owe their current players tens of millions of pounds?
Are they in serious breach of PL financial rules?
Are they signing players for huge sums while unable to register them due to those rules?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
does any of that matter? thats not the point im raising thats different feel free to create a thread on that if you want.
IM asking can you not see the irony of a club who have large levels of debt complaining about a team with large levels of debt buying players?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No. End thread.
posted on 15/7/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by rooney_hernandez (U7012)
posted 58 seconds ago
Also, your quoted figures are incorrect. Here as the latest set of accounts - go have a look for yourself and come back when you have questions
https://ir.manutd.com/~/media/Files/M/Manutd-IR/documents/2021-mu-plc-form-20-f.pdf
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thats over a year old that info
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you actually sure? The club's financial period end is 30 June; companies (particularly, PLCs) are required to have their accounts audited before publication so, y'know, they don't just print "we make 100 billion pounds a week..."
Those audits take MONTHS, and that's on the assumption of timely and accurate source information from the internal finance and accounting functions at United.
All in all, you won't see the FY22 accounts before September. So, if you're telling me that you're an auditor at PwC (you're not, you wouldn't have made it through the first exam) AND you're on the United audit AND MUFC's internal teams somehow pulled together all the requisite information FIFTEEN DAYS AFTER THE PERIOD END I will LITERALLY eat my nuts, film it, put it on YouTube, throw up the contents and paint "I'm sorry I doubted you, whodunnit" on the camera lens
posted on 15/7/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 45 seconds ago
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
OP, why are you foaming at the chops about United all the time?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
give examples?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
https://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/446423
posted on 15/7/22
Man has mortgage and keeps his payments up and has no defaulted debts and goes and buys a huge TV and everyone is happy.
Man has mortgage and can’t keep up the repayments nor his credit card debts nor his council tax and still goes and buys large TV. Not everyone is happy.
Thus concludes Robb’s economics lesson.
posted on 15/7/22
comment by Robb 🎶 Chrissy, wake up! 🎶 (U22716)
posted 17 seconds ago
Man has mortgage and keeps his payments up and has no defaulted debts and goes and buys a huge TV and everyone is happy.
Man has mortgage and can’t keep up the repayments nor his credit card debts nor his council tax and still goes and buys large TV. Not everyone is happy.
Thus concludes Robb’s economics lesson.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
But but but but they both have debt.
Page 1 of 3