or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 95 comments are related to an article called:

William Carvalho

Page 1 of 4

posted on 18/6/16

A disciplined athletic powerful black footballer. Jose must have an eye on him. Dream signing for him. Fact he's Portuguese is a bonus.

As for Gomes......any better than Herrera? Not for me.

posted on 18/6/16

Gomes has been Portugal's best footballer in this tourney. Extremely graceful with the ball and very rarely loses it

posted on 18/6/16

Bang average. No better than Wanyama or Kondogbia. Next.

posted on 18/6/16

Gomes has been totally invisible today.

posted on 18/6/16

Robb, I may well be wrong, but there appears to be dozens of players you like more than the ones we already have.

posted on 18/6/16

comment by Stretford_Ender85 (U10955)
posted 1 minute ago
Gomes has been totally invisible today.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You're watching a different game then. He's passed the ball around extremely well. Controlled the tempo

posted on 18/6/16

comment by manusince52 (U9692)
posted 14 seconds ago
Robb, I may well be wrong, but there appears to be dozens of players you like more than the ones we already have.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

That's because there are dozens of players out there better than what we have. Nothing wrong with scouting the possibilities

posted on 18/6/16

Robbs ideal summer:

Sell everyone (except fellaini and DDG)

Buy 20 new players.

Robbs ideal Autumn:

Complain about the 20 new players

posted on 18/6/16

Robb

Hes done nothing. Controlled tempo? Are you on drugs? He's yet to make a telling pass or shot in game. Now iv said it, he will probably get winner but he's not controlled anything.

posted on 18/6/16

Think he's played really well today but not sure of he would be a priority

posted on 18/6/16

comment by Stretford_Ender85 (U10955)
posted 1 minute ago
Robb

Hes done nothing. Controlled tempo? Are you on drugs? He's yet to make a telling pass or shot in game. Now iv said it, he will probably get winner but he's not controlled anything.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

you haven't watched the game

posted on 18/6/16

William carvahlo that is

posted on 18/6/16

As for new players this summer we need a few decent ones. Only DDG, smalling, Shaw and Martial should be guaranteed places in the side. That doesn't mean we need 7 new starters. But lots of work still needs to be done

posted on 18/6/16

I have Robb. What did he do? He's that much of a threat his manager just took him off.

posted on 18/6/16

4 goals and 3 goals were his return in last two seasons. That's not screaming game changing attacking midfielder to me.

posted on 18/6/16

comment by Stretford_Ender85 (U10955)
posted 10 seconds ago
4 goals and 3 goals were his return in last two seasons. That's not screaming game changing attacking midfielder to me.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He's not a game changing attacking mid though. He's more like a Carrick who keeps the game ticking over

Even with that he provided the assist for Portugal's goal against Iceland and today his smart play helped make the penalty

posted on 18/6/16

This Portugal team is poor.

Worst I've seen.

posted on 18/6/16

There playing Austria. And struggling

posted on 18/6/16

They are in worst group by far and haven't won a game yet and only have a goal to show for it.

Portugal are a bang average team.

posted on 18/6/16

Gomes is middling. Portugese Ander Herrera. And for the price quoted? Phbbt! Andre Gomes is no difference-maker.

Carvalho is middling. Danilo better.

posted on 18/6/16

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/6/16

Nobody should be guaranteed places. But I agree the 4 you have mentioned are almost.
But I think Darmian and Morgan will have much better seasons this year. Lingaard will hold down his place, Rashford will get a lot of games, Blind will play more often than not. CBJ and Mensah I hope will get some time. Rooney will play more often than not, Who knows even Jones may come good.
I would like to see 2 or 3 players signed. A striker like Lacazette, a defensive midfielder like Dier and a winger like Mahrez. But mainly a striker.

posted on 18/6/16

Kante over Carvalho. Schneiderlin still too. Not writing him off yet.

As for Gomes? He looks average to me. We shouldn't be spending 30m on another so so player. He's not bad but he's far from great.

posted on 18/6/16

This Portugal side would be better off without Ronaldo IMO. Everything has to go through him and he seems the type to bring about bad feeling when he kicks off if the ball isn't passed to him

posted on 18/6/16

Better off without him? Nuno Gomes still around? Robb you are a clown

Page 1 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment