or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 394 comments are related to an article called:

A soft penalty in a crucial game

Page 1 of 16

posted on 9/5/18

Joke of a decision tbh , the movement of the ball should have made it obvious to the ref. He’s argubwly got a better view than anyone in it as well

Shambles .

Need hearts to win tonight and then a draw with the hobos in last game.

I’d resigned myself to finishing 4th a few weeks ago but we could still get 2nd if hertz do us a turn tonight

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 9/5/18

I actually think the referee has maybe the worst view on the park

McLean gets the first touch then Morelos gets a touch, but from S.McLeans angle he'll only see K.McLean touching it

Aberdeen should've had the game wrapped up at half time, thought Rangers had the better of the 2nd half so a draw was a fair result

Goss was lucky to stay on the park

posted on 9/5/18

I haven’t seen the incident but was a clear pen for me. Meaningless game anyway, which is why they were showing full match highlights of the Dundee game on the BBC last night. Glad our license fee is going on proper competitive games, where there’s something meaningful at stake.

Anyway, you guys are sorted for 2nd now. The only thing that can stop you is if for whatever reason, Celtic take a disliking to you, but I cannot see that happening.

posted on 9/5/18

Nah McLean is staring right at it from a couple yards. How he doesn’t see morels touch it is ridiculous

posted on 9/5/18

*morelos

posted on 9/5/18

https://twitter.com/james1872_/status/993928958373777408?s=21

Can see in that video there, he really couldn’t have had a better view

posted on 9/5/18

If the ref had any doubt it shouldn't have been given.

Terrible decision that may have cost us a win.

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 9/5/18

he never had any doubt though, he pointed straight at McLean saying he got the ball first

I actually thought Alnwick was lucky when he completely took Considine out the game when he was nowhere the ball

thoughts?

posted on 9/5/18

Except he didn’t get the ball first, morelos did.

posted on 9/5/18

I’d agree it got a bit out of control at times after that discipline wise but you can understand that when ref gives a dodgy pen against you

posted on 9/5/18

https://twitter.com/naebull/status/993931330973990912?s=21

Better view of the incident

posted on 9/5/18

Hard one for the ref to call

We all had to watch it back to see who got the touch

The football on show last night was murder

posted on 9/5/18

Fitbaw was murder

If it’s hard for him to call then he shouldn’t call it. If he’s the least bit unsure then it’s no pen .

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 9/5/18

McLean was sure he did but, he pointed straight at McLean which means he was sure and that's why he gave it

we all know McLean has previous for getting big decisions wrong

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

McLean's also a lying khunt for what he said after the game.

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 9/5/18

Shinnie was running the game last night and Rangers players took it in turns to cement him towards the end of the first half

Holt and Goss both with shockers

that's 4/5 horrible tackles that have gone relatively unpunished in the last few days

posted on 9/5/18

I don't think you can hang the ref on it

He's got it wrong , but he's assumed McLean gets the touch .. and if he thinks that he has to give it

He's been duped by McLean

posted on 9/5/18



Anything to avoid saying it wasn’t a pen

Laughable

posted on 9/5/18

“don't think you can hang the ref on it

He's got it wrong , but he's assumed McLean gets the touch .. and if he thinks that he has to give it

He's been duped by McLean”


Yeah well he’s assumed wrong

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

“McLean's also a lying khunt for what he said after the game.”


Kenny or his uncle Steven ?

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 9/5/18

nothing being said about the shocking tackles on Shinnie

doesn't surprise me tbh

comment by lauders (U9757)

posted on 9/5/18

Draw a fair result so only ourselves to blame.
Should never have been in this position anyway

posted on 9/5/18

Meh Aberdeen like to find ah it out so I’m not sure they can moan about getting it back. Don’t even think they mentioned it?

Page 1 of 16

Sign in if you want to comment