or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 394 comments are related to an article called:

A soft penalty in a crucial game

Page 4 of 16

comment by Joejoe (U7141)

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Wieghorst (U12621)
posted 2 minutes ago
You sure he has signed?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yup

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 1 minute ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Sure he got the ball but he fouled Morelos to do so.....last night you were lying that it a penalty now your saying "aye but....." it was a terrible decision and altered the course of the first half and the outcome of the game.

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Dustin Hoffman Touched my Tuppence (U19139)
posted 11 seconds ago
comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 5 minutes ago
Don’t know why you lot are complaining, yeah it was soft but earlier on in the game he gave Rangers a free kick for Cosgrove challenge on someone where he got the ball first so same thing just Morelos did it in the box
-----------------------------------------------

You know fine well why we are complaining.

McLean dived to con the referee into giving a non existent penalty.

Only way that pashy Aberdeen team could muster a goal.

Are you not a bit gutted that Aberdeen blew their big chance of securing second last night Gilhaus? At home. Against a team in turmoil.

Or are you just delighted you managed to scrape your first point against us this season?

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rangers should have had at least two reds the ref was shocking

But yeah even tho a point wasn’t enough it was a better performance against them after the recent results

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 52 seconds ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He wrongly gave a penalty that affected the result and the flow of the game. End of story.

posted on 9/5/18

* not lying....saying

posted on 9/5/18

The red had a mare like said rangers should have had two reds at least but if you start giving free kicks for non challenges then it was a definite pen going by S.Macleans book

comment by Joejoe (U7141)

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 3 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------
or you could engage your brain and say that he got the Cosgrove one wrong .... so are you saying that two wrongs make a right. Your basing you argument on the fact that a similar instance took place. I would just look at the incident we are talking about. Was it a foul, no, therfore no penalty. Not Rocket Science, thankfully for you !

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

McInnes was telling everyone that last night was Aberdeen's biggest game of the season....he should've told the fans...huge blocks of empty seats . Joke club!

posted on 9/5/18

Morelos looked a broken man from what i saw of him, his confidence must be well low, he will be getting sent off sometime soon. He was giving it the big un to the aberdeen fans when Rangers scored, he flew in to tackles and wrestled a guy to the ground at one point im sure

https://twitter.com/gibbygibbo1/status/993930286722355200

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

comment by delboy82 (U7141)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 3 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------
or you could engage your brain and say that he got the Cosgrove one wrong .... so are you saying that two wrongs make a right. Your basing you argument on the fact that a similar instance took place. I would just look at the incident we are talking about. Was it a foul, no, therfore no penalty. Not Rocket Science, thankfully for you !
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he got the Cosgrove one wrong but if you give free kicks for that then the ref has to continue in the same manner

posted on 9/5/18

All those yellows mount up eh.

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Dustin Hoffman Touched my Tuppence (U19139)
posted 2 minutes ago
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rangers should have had at least two reds the ref was shocking
--------------------------------------------------------------

It was Aberdeen that benefitted from the shocking ref decision.

Yip there were a few meaty challenges but they were appropriately dealt with by yellow cards.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How’s should have seen red for his first challenge so not appropriately dealt with

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 6 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Or perhaps he is a fcking useless ref who got both these decisions wrong.

Ours was way more costly though.

That cannot be disputed

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/18

Goss not hows

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Dustin Hoffman Touched my Tuppence (U19139)
posted 8 seconds ago
Yes he got the Cosgrove one wrong but if you give free kicks for that then the ref has to continue in the same manner
--------------------------------------------

Oh lord!

So the referee is allowed to change the rules of the game during the game because he makes a mistake!!??

That is beyond ridiculous even for a bitter Aberdeen fan.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
So he gives a free kick that wasn’t he has to keep his same poor standards throughout

comment by Joejoe (U7141)

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 46 seconds ago
comment by delboy82 (U7141)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 3 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------
or you could engage your brain and say that he got the Cosgrove one wrong .... so are you saying that two wrongs make a right. Your basing you argument on the fact that a similar instance took place. I would just look at the incident we are talking about. Was it a foul, no, therfore no penalty. Not Rocket Science, thankfully for you !
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he got the Cosgrove one wrong but if you give free kicks for that then the ref has to continue in the same manner
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So if a player dives and wins a foul every dive in the game is therfore a foul? You do realise this is what you have just put forward ?!?! Cos the ref gave one as a foul he needs to give the rest as one.

You are a genius

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Partick Bateman (U14112)
posted 6 seconds ago
comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 6 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Or perhaps he is a fcking useless ref who got both these decisions wrong.

Ours was way more costly though.

That cannot be disputed
------------------------------------------------------------------
Fan ny sh!thouse will dispute it.......I'm actually doubting he saw the game.

posted on 9/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Joejoe (U7141)

posted on 9/5/18

comment by meuandcoop - Green & Whyte=Shyte (U5293)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by Partick Bateman (U14112)
posted 6 seconds ago
comment by Fan Gillhaus 1903 (U3339)
posted 6 minutes ago
Simple fact is he gave a free kick for a challenge where Cosgrove clearly got the ball if he was giving free kicks for that then it was definitely a pen and it would have been double standards aye
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Or perhaps he is a fcking useless ref who got both these decisions wrong.

Ours was way more costly though.

That cannot be disputed
------------------------------------------------------------------
Fan ny sh!thouse will dispute it.......I'm actually doubting he saw the game.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
judging by the stands he wasnt the only one who missed it

posted on 9/5/18

Dinks it to the back post

posted on 9/5/18

comment by Wieghorst (U12621)
posted 12 minutes ago
You sure he has signed?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Eeeeeeeh aye.

What makes you think he hasn't? Phil?

Page 4 of 16

Sign in if you want to comment