or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 192 comments are related to an article called:

The value of Keiran Tierney ...

Page 1 of 8

posted on 10/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by JFK (U8919)

posted on 10/5/18

i think you lose more than a player if he goes.

he's huge for the fans as well

he is the one we need to keep and thankfully he is the one most likely to stay.

posted on 10/5/18

Yeah he’s a cracking player

I think the fact he’s a Celtic fan prob means Celtic will be more confident knocking back 10-15m cos they know he won’t spit the dummy

20m I think Celtic would sell at , whether someone offers that who knows. Talk of Bournemouth wanting him this summer but I’m not sure he’d leave for a team like that

posted on 10/5/18

Hopefully Utd bound. Great player. 2 best left backs in Britain are Scottish, what are the chances?

posted on 10/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 10/5/18

This will sound ridiculous but I would actually be gutted if we sold him for £20M

I honestly don't see any reason why we couldn't ask for £30M +

Totally agree JFK 👍 we would undoubtedly be losing more than just a player , he's a guy who fans can identify with

Clubs have to be on the verge of offering Celtic a price they can't turn down for him....when you look at some of the dross being sold for silly money

posted on 10/5/18

15m.

Still got a lot of learning to do at the top level, needs to do it at that level consistently and add more in attacking areas to be compared to Robertson.

Can't see him leaving unless it was to United this summer.

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 10/5/18

he's one of a kind

you look at him n know it's you inside him, a fan that's living the dream

posted on 10/5/18

comment by Dustin Hoffman Touched my Tuppence (U19139)
posted 2 minutes ago
£15-20m.

Very very good player.

He seems happy at celtic but for the sake of his career he should go in the next couple of years.

Look at what Robertson has achieved at Liverpool.

Instead of gearing up for another routine easy domestic cup win over motherwell, Robertson is preparing for the Champions League final against Real Madrid.

That is a different footballing planet that Tierney should want to test himself and see if he is capable of being part of.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Can't disagree much with that

posted on 10/5/18

comment by Baz tard (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago

Hopefully Utd bound. Great player. 2 best left backs in Britain are Scottish, what are the chances
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Too far.

He's not better than Rose, Mendy, Robertson or Alonso.

Stick him in that next level with Bertrand etc

posted on 10/5/18

comment by Greatteamswinit4times- a terrible enemy (U6008)
posted 8 minutes ago
15 million would do it wouldn't it?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I would sincerely hope not 👍

posted on 10/5/18

From people that are supposedly in the know, he wants to do a mcstay, whether it's true and whether he keeps that same opinion is another matter

posted on 10/5/18

“you look at him n know it's you inside him,”




I bet you do

posted on 10/5/18

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 16 seconds ago
comment by Baz tard (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago

Hopefully Utd bound. Great player. 2 best left backs in Britain are Scottish, what are the chances
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Too far.

He's not better than Rose, Mendy, Robertson or Alonso.

Stick him in that next level with Bertrand etc
----------------------------------------------------------------------
British left backs I meant. Not expensive foreigners. Mendy has done nothing yet to be up there, and I think Robertson is better than rose overall.

comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)

posted on 10/5/18

he's better than Rose and Bertrand ffs

posted on 10/5/18

you look at him n know it's you inside him
_____________________________

Well, well, well. I think we can all draw our own conclusions from this statement.

posted on 10/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Paddy (U5235)

posted on 10/5/18

Could easily see him doing a McStay and spending his career with us - loves Celtic.

However I wouldn't hold it against him to want to try his hand in another country (most likely England). If we can keep him for [hopefully] 10IAR that would be great, he would only be 24 that summer so probably not even at his peak by then

posted on 10/5/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Paddy (U5235)

posted on 10/5/18

Smid - that statement is both and

posted on 10/5/18

comment by Celtic kiwi (U21131)
posted 5 minutes ago

From people that are supposedly in the know, he wants to do a mcstay, whether it's true and whether he keeps that same opinion is another matter
---------------------------------------------------------------------
He's failed, he would had to have won close to fck all for that

posted on 10/5/18

I reckon Kieran has got ambition

posted on 10/5/18

comment by Baz tard (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 16 seconds ago
comment by Baz tard (U19119)
posted 4 minutes ago

Hopefully Utd bound. Great player. 2 best left backs in Britain are Scottish, what are the chances
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Too far.

He's not better than Rose, Mendy, Robertson or Alonso.

Stick him in that next level with Bertrand etc
----------------------------------------------------------------------
British left backs I meant. Not expensive foreigners. Mendy has done nothing yet to be up there, and I think Robertson is better than rose overall.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Robertson is.

Tierney isn't better than Rose though or even Bertrand.

One is a CL winner the other the first choice for England playing well regularly (until this season) in PL and in Europe.

comment by Joejoe (U7141)

posted on 10/5/18

Man Utd are intertested ........

Naw its actually Bournemouth that are intersted.

I think that would be a decent move for him, he would be guaranteed football there and can then move onto a bigger club from that. He moves to a big club their is a much higher chance he plays less often that will hinder his development. either go to a smaller team in the EPL or stay with Celtic if he wants to be the best player he can be.

posted on 10/5/18

Tierney has a 6 year deal, he loves the club...he might just stay for 4 or 5 years and still have time to try his hand in EPL.

Page 1 of 8

Sign in if you want to comment